A three-judge panel struck down a state law that would have cut the size of Nashville's 40-member Metro Council in half.
Why it matters: The 2-1 ruling is another victory for Metro in its legal showdown with the state. The Republican-controlled legislature passed a series of laws targeting the capital city last year after the Metro Council rejected efforts to bring the Republican National Convention to Nashville .
- Opponents of the law slashing the council size feared it would create political anarchy in city government through a chaotic and unprecedented redistricting process that would pit council members against one another.
Flashback: The law initially required Metro to slash the size of its council from 40 to 20 prior to the August 2023 election. But the city won a reprieve when the three-judge panel ruled that Metro did not need to meet that tight deadline .
- Even after that ruling, many city leaders feared they would eventually have to comply and cut the council down for future elections.
The latest: In their Monday afternoon ruling, a majority of the judges agreed with the city's argument that the law violated a provision of the Tennessee Constitution that protects local governments from laws that single them out.
- In a statement following the court win, Nashville Mayor Freddie O'Connell highlighted a 2015 vote in which voters rejected a proposal to reduce the size of the council.
- "I'm pleased with the court's decision to allow Nashville to have the authority to choose the size of its Metropolitan Council," O'Connell said.
Zoom out: Metro is yet to lose a court ruling over one of the laws aimed at Nashville.
What they're saying: "This ruling meaningfully preserves the will of Nashville voters," Metro's associate director of law Allison Bussell tells Axios. "When electing to consolidate in 1962, Nashville voters approved a Charter setting Metro Nashville's Council size at 40."
- "The Metro Council Reduction Act was one of several General Assembly efforts to impose its will on Metro Nashville in ways that the Tennessee Constitution expressly prohibits."
Editor's note: This story has been updated with a statement from Nashville Mayor Freddie O'Connell.
Comments / 0