Orioles "spicy" proposed blockbuster lands game-changing outfield star

The Baltimore Orioles have the potential to shake up Major League Baseball at this year's trade deadline.

After years of suffering losing seasons, the Orioles built up their farm system to levels of stardom that may never be matched again. Top prospect after top prospect has graduated to the big leagues, but there's somehow always more waiting in the pipeline.

Now, though, the Orioles have expectations. They ended play Saturday with a two-game lead atop the loaded American League East. After losing in the first round of the postseason a year ago, Baltimore is desperate to make a deep October run.

To do so, they may need to part with some of that immense prospect capital. One area the Orioles could improve at the deadline is center field, where Cedric Mullins has struggled all year. And one hypothetical trade proposed Saturday would turn the baseball world upside-down.

Steve Perrault of Bleacher Report discussed a hypothetical trade between the Orioles and the Chicago White Sox on a live stream. In the deal, the Orioles would acquire center fielder Luis Robert Jr. straight-up in exchange for No. 1 overall prospect Jackson Holliday.

"Adding a name like Luis Robert to the Orioles lineup, I think, would make them if not the World Series favorite, at least the American League favorite," Perrault said.

It's undeniable that Robert has the talent to make the Orioles terrifying for the rest of 2024. The defending AL Silver Slugger winner has a .793 OPS with 11 homers even in an injury-shortened season that got off to a slow start.

But would the Orioles really part with Holliday, who has been one of the highest-touted prospects in Baltimore's recent history, along with superstars Adley Rutschman and Gunnar Henderson?

"You never know with prospects," Perrault said of Holliday. "Maybe he's not going to be great."

And this is the real crux of the issue. Whether or not a deal like this one for Robert is on the table, at some point, the Orioles may have to decide if going for glory this season is worth holding onto Holliday for the future.

The Orioles have the top farm system in Major League Baseball. They could even afford to lose him if he ends up being good-to-great," Perrault said.

MLB history is littered with cautionary tales about prospects who were traded for underwhelming returns and who went on to be superstars. But we never hear the flip side: deals teams turned down by holding onto prospects that never quite panned out.

More MLB: Phillies discussed surprising deadline trade with Orioles, per insider