Embattled Oakland Mayor Sheng Thao faces looming budget crisis, recall vote
By Katie Nielsen,
2 days ago
In Oakland Tuesday, the city's budget woes and a pending recall vote were in the spotlight as supporters and opponents of Mayor Sheng Thao held dueling rallies a short distance apart ahead of her "State of the City" address.
During her address, Thao highlighted crime-reduction strategies, investments and developments in Oakland, as well as progress on the homelessness issues.
"Looking back at where we were, where we are today is nothing short of inspiring," the mayor said at one point, taking an optimistic tone. "Sometimes in the day-to-day grind, we forget to look at the bigger picture. And when I look at the deeply impactful work we have accomplished together, I am truly amazed."
While the mayor painted one picture of the state of the city, a number of council members say the city is in serious trouble because of the budget issues, and the Mayor's lack of transparency is just making it worse.
Tensions were running high in Oakland's Chinatown Tuesday morning as protestors supporting Thao staying in office traded jabs with those who want to see her recalled.
According to the mayor's office, the sale is still on track to go through. But instead of the city getting payments over the next few months, the majority of the money wouldn't be available until the end of the fiscal year, leaving a $48 million hole to fill.
"We are in a bad budget situation. We need to be open and honest about where we are and what we need to cut," said Councilmember Janani Ramachandran, who has been raising alarms about the Coliseum deal .
She says the city is already working from a contingency, worst-case scenario budget and the city administrator's office us making cuts to balance the budget, but she says what no one is talking about is where those cuts are coming from.
"People deserve to know the truth and as much push back as I'm getting for exposing these realities, I'm going to keep doing it so the public has a sense of what's actually going on and what to anticipate," said Ramachandran.
KPIX's Katie Nielsen pressed Mayor Thao for answers after the rally.
When Nielsen told the mayor, "Councilmembers said they're not getting any answers about where the contingency budget cuts are coming from," and asked for comment, Thao replied, "All the documents are already published so everyone can read it."
When Nielsen pressed the mayor and asked if there were cuts to police or fire at this point?, Thao said, "Absolutely not."
Councilmember Treva Reid says those cuts are inevitable because public safety is the single largest expense from the city's general fund. There's no way to close the budget gap without making drastic cuts to public safety.
"There are no details and when there are no details there is a deeper degree of mis-trust," says Council Member Reid. She questions whether the lack of transparency from the mayor's office has to do with the possibility of her being recalled.
"I believe that fear and desperation will lead to a lot of things and I believe that we are feeling the weight of that level of pressure in this election period," says Reid.
That’s not all she’s facing. The city is a disaster. Downtown is vacant. The hotels are leaving and the road to the airport is a ghost town.. crime is running rampant so I think she’s got a lot of problems to deal with and it doesn’t appear that she’s up to the task
Get updates delivered to you daily. Free and customizable.
It’s essential to note our commitment to transparency:
Our Terms of Use acknowledge that our services may not always be error-free, and our Community Standards emphasize our discretion in enforcing policies. As a platform hosting over 100,000 pieces of content published daily, we cannot pre-vet content, but we strive to foster a dynamic environment for free expression and robust discourse through safety guardrails of human and AI moderation.