Dock Ellis Foundation: Challenging the "Runaway" Label for Black and Brown Children

Equalizing Attention and Resources for Missing ChildrenPhoto byDock Ellis Foundation

In the United States, the disappearance of a child is a heart-wrenching event that demands immediate action and attention. However, not all cases receive the same level of urgency or media coverage, particularly when it comes to minority children. This disparity often leaves Black and Brown children at a grave disadvantage, labeled as runaways rather than victims, and subsequently denied the life-saving attention they deserve.

One significant challenge in addressing this issue lies within the criteria set by the AMBER Alert system. To issue an AMBER Alert, several stringent conditions must be fulfilled: there must be reasonable evidence of an abduction, the child must be believed to be in imminent danger, there should be sufficient descriptive information about the victim and abductor, the child must be under 17, and their data must be entered into the National Crime Information Center system. When these criteria are not met, minority children are frequently labeled as runaways, a categorization that severely limits the resources and media attention devoted to their recovery.

Take, for example, the case of 13-year-old Janiyah McMichael from Gary, Indiana. Missing since August 11, 2024, her disappearance has been met with minimal media attention and no qualified search efforts by law enforcement. Despite the Dock Ellis Foundation's persistent requests for an Alert, law enforcement has ignored the request and has yet to provide any updates regarding her disappearance. Shortly after the communication law enforcement placed an image of Janiyah on their social media post labeling her a runaway, 6 days after her disappearance. Janiyah's case exemplifies the systemic issues that minority families face: when a child is labeled a runaway, the urgency to find them diminishes, media coverage is scant, and fewer police resources are allocated to their recovery.

Contrast this with the recent case in Texas, where an AMBER Alert was promptly issued for a 13-year-old girl from Princeton. Despite initial police treatment of the case as a potential runaway, the presence of a vehicle possibly involved in her disappearance, and the state's protocols regarding juvenile consent, resulted in swift action. Media coverage was extensive, and resources were mobilized quickly to help locate her.

The discrepancy in these two cases highlights a broader, troubling pattern: minority children do not receive the same level of urgency and national awareness as their white counterparts. This systemic bias underscores the need for a reevaluation of how missing child cases are handled, ensuring that all children, regardless of race or background, receive equal attention and resources.

The Dock Ellis Foundation believes it is imperative to address these disparities. We advocate for reforms in the AMBER Alert system to ensure that it serves all communities equitably. The lives of Black and Brown children are as precious and valuable as any, and their cases should be met with the same immediacy and seriousness.

The foundation calls on law enforcement agencies, policymakers, and the public to recognize and correct these inequities. Only through collective awareness and action can we ensure that every missing child is given the best possible chance of being found and returned home safely.

Visit Dock Ellis Foundation