Car Insurance Rates Have Increased by Nearly 20% - Here’s How To Pay Less

Paying for car insurance can be frustrating. Not only is it expensive, but few insurers are willing to negotiate, as rates typically are regulated by states and cannot be adjusted or changed for individual policyholders.

Even more difficult for drivers is the rising cost. Car insurance rates have surged by nearly 20%, with the July consumer price index (CPI) showing an increase of 18.6% in the past year.

In 2024, the average annual cost for car insurance is $1,715, according to auto club AAA, which is an increase of over $500 since 2019.

Fortunately, there are still ways to boost your financial fitness by lowering how much you're paying. Here are a few ways you can save money.

Make Money: 8 things to do if you're barely scraping by financially

1. Shop around — then, negotiate

One of the best ways to save money on car insurance is to shop around when your policy comes up for renewal.

By comparing quotes from multiple insurers, you can get the car insurance policy you need at the best possible price.

If you find a better deal with another insurance company, talk to an agent who works for your current insurer and see if you can find ways to lower your costs to match what the other insurer is offering.

2. Raise your deductible

If you want to lower your premium costs, one option is to talk to your insurance company about raising your deductible.

However, proceed with caution before making this switch. If you later make an insurance claim, you will first have to pay the deductible before your insurer will start covering your costs. Make sure you can afford the deductible.

3. Reduce your insurance coverage

If you have an older vehicle that isn’t worth much money, you might consider dropping your collision and comprehensive coverage.

This should save you a substantial amount in premium costs. However, remember that without these coverages, you will have to pay for any repair costs to your own car out of pocket. So, this approach makes the most sense if you are prepared to replace your car if something bad happens to it.

Enjoying our content? Click the Follow button above to see more from us.

4. Ask about bundling discounts

Insurance companies often offer discounts to customers who insure more than just their cars with the company.

Ask your insurer how much you can save by bundling coverage. If the savings are large, you might consider purchasing your home insurance, auto insurance, and other types of insurance all from the same provider.

5. See if you can get other discounts

Your insurance company likely offers many other types of discounts. So, it’s important to talk to your insurance agent or company representative at renewal to find out if you qualify for any of these price breaks.

For example, you might lower your costs by being a safe driver, taking driving courses, or being a loyal customer. Check with your provider about getting a better rate.

6. Keep in touch with your agent

If you have an insurance agent, contact that individual to learn more about how you can lower your costs. Agents are expert professionals who likely know about ways to save that you might easily overlook.

So, before your policy renews the next time, have a chat with your agent or an insurance company representative.

7. Compare the insurance costs for different vehicles

Are you planning to buy a car around the time your policy will renew? If so, do your homework and find out how much it costs to insure the models you are considering buying.

Car insurance costs can vary from vehicle to vehicle, so you might want to get estimates from your insurance provider before you go to a dealership.

Buying a model that is cheaper to insure could save you money for years to come.

Bottom line

It can be expensive to pay for insurance for your vehicle, but there are ways to get ahead financially by saving on car insurance.

It’s also important to factor in other costs of car ownership before you buy a new car. Be sure you understand costs related to loan or lease payments, gas, and repair and maintenance before you plunk down the money on a new ride.

Money tips that can work for everyone

No matter what your bank account balance is, there's always an opportunity to optimize and improve your finances. Here's a quick checklist of things you can look at today.

Focus on paying off your debt . Debt can hold you back from making progress with your overall financial well-being. Aside from cutting expenses, there are tools that can help you pay off debt faster like balance transfer credit cards and debt counseling.

Earning extra income can give you breathing room. If finances are tight, earning some extra money to supplement your income can make a huge difference. A new job is one option to consider, but if you're not ready to make a big change or already retired, a part-time side job could be a better choice.

Cut your expenses. It sounds painful and so not fun, but it doesn't have to be. Take a look at your biggest expenses because that's where you'll probably find the biggest savings. For example, auto insurance rates have been soaring so shopping around for a new insurance company can be the fastest way to cut your bill. Also, look for ways to cut your grocery bill (despite rising inflation).