Holey Moley NY Bagel Working on Third Location

Holey Moley NY Bagel , a locally owned and operated cafe specializing in authentic NYC bagels, is preparing to open a new location in Atlantic Beach at 469 Atlantic Boulevard, Suite 9 .

The company’s third location is set to move into the former home of Allstate Insurance in Laura Plaza , according to a recent plan review application submitted to the Florida Department of Business & Professional Regulation. While the application is still being processed, the new location is expected to open later this year, likely in the Summer of 2024 . When it opens, customers can expect delicious, freshly baked, authentic NYC bagels shipped daily from the Big Apple.

Holey Moley NY Bagel has two Jacksonville locations at 8616 Baymeadows Road and 2777 University Boulevard W, Unit 24. Both locations feature a variety of bagels and cream cheese flavors, such as plain, cinnamon dust, s’mores, mixed berry, confetti, and more. The company also specializes in breakfast sandwiches, such as a lox bagel made with cream cheese, tomatoes, onions, cucumbers, and capers. There’s also a handful of savory bagel sandwiches, including a chicken BLT.

When the new Atlantic City location opens later this year, its hours will likely be Monday through Saturday from 7 a.m. to 1 p.m. and Sunday from 8 a.m. to 1 p.m., like the other two locations. This will be the first time the company has expanded beyond the city of Jacksonville. Holey Moley NY Bagel is not to be confused with Holey Moley Bagel Bar, a separate, locally owned New York-style bagel shop in Orange Park.

Keep up with What Now Jacksonville’s restaurant, retail, and real estate scoop by subscribing to our newsletter , liking us on Facebook , and following us on Twitter . Opening a restaurant? Browse our Preferred Partners .