Who Suffers More in a Bad Marriage: Women or Men?

When a marriage turns sour, the question often arises: who suffers more, women or men? The answer isn't as simple as one might think. While society tends to focus on women’s experiences, men endure their own set of challenges.

Both genders suffer in distinct, sometimes overlooked, ways that go beyond the obvious.

Photo bymicheile hendersononUnsplash

The Silent Struggles of Men

Men in bad marriages often face silent struggles that aren't easily recognized. Society expects men to be the stoic pillars of strength, which can make it difficult for them to admit that they’re unhappy.

This expectation creates a kind of emotional isolation where men might not even acknowledge their suffering to themselves. When they do, they often find it challenging to seek support, leaving them to bear the burden alone.

One non-obvious point is how men often internalize their unhappiness, which can manifest in unexpected ways. Rather than openly addressing issues, men might withdraw, focusing more on work, hobbies, or other distractions.

This withdrawal isn't always about avoiding conflict but rather a way of coping with feelings they don’t know how to express. Over time, this emotional distancing can erode their sense of connection to their partner, leading to a quiet, profound loneliness.

The Unseen Cost of Emotional Labor for Women

Women, on the other hand, often carry the weight of emotional labor in a bad marriage. This isn’t just about managing household tasks or caring for children; it’s about the constant effort to maintain the emotional climate of the relationship.

Women might feel responsible for smoothing over conflicts, keeping the peace, and making sure everyone’s needs are met—even at the cost of their own well-being.

One overlooked aspect of this emotional labor is how it can lead to a deep sense of resentment. Women might find themselves feeling unappreciated, not just by their spouse, but by society at large.

The expectation that women should naturally excel at nurturing can make them feel guilty for wanting more from the relationship or for feeling exhausted by their role. This guilt can turn into a quiet, internalized frustration that slowly chips away at their self-esteem.

The Burden of Social Expectations

Both men and women suffer under the weight of social expectations in a bad marriage, but in different ways. Men might feel the pressure to be the providers and protectors, even when their marriage is failing. This expectation can lead them to stay in a bad situation longer than they should, out of a sense of duty or fear of being judged as failures.

Women, meanwhile, might feel trapped by the expectation that they should be the ones to hold the marriage together. The societal pressure to be a “good wife” can make it hard for them to acknowledge that the relationship isn’t working. This pressure can lead women to stay in unhealthy marriages, believing that leaving would mean they’ve failed in their role.

The Two Sides of Resilience

Both men and women who pride themselves on their resilience might stay in a bad marriage longer than those who are more willing to acknowledge their vulnerabilities. This resilience, while it helps them cope with difficulties, can also blind them to the reality that they’re in a situation that isn’t improving.

For men, resilience might look like working harder or burying themselves in other responsibilities, believing they can fix the problems if they just try hard enough. For women, it might look like putting on a brave face and carrying on with the day-to-day tasks, even when they’re emotionally exhausted. In both cases, resilience can keep them stuck in a bad marriage, delaying the recognition that things need to change.

The Unexpected Impact on Identity

A bad marriage can have a profound impact on a person’s sense of identity, in ways that aren’t immediately obvious. For men, this might involve questioning their masculinity or their role as a provider. They might struggle with feelings of inadequacy, wondering if they’re failing as a husband or father. This internal conflict can lead to a deep sense of shame that’s difficult to talk about.

Women, on the other hand, might grapple with a loss of self. In trying to meet the needs of their spouse and children, they might lose sight of their own desires and goals. Over time, they might begin to feel like they’ve lost their sense of who they are outside of their roles as wife and mother. This loss of identity can lead to feelings of emptiness and confusion, especially if the marriage ends.

Conclusion: A Different Kind of Suffering

So, who suffers more in a bad marriage—women or men? The truth is, both genders suffer in ways that are deeply personal and often invisible to others. Men might grapple with unacknowledged emotional pain and a crisis of identity, while women might face the silent burden of emotional labor and a loss of self. The suffering isn’t necessarily greater for one gender over the other, but it is different, shaped by societal expectations and individual coping mechanisms.

Understanding these differences is key to supporting those in bad marriages. It’s not about comparing who suffers more, but about recognizing the unique challenges each person faces and finding ways to address them. Only by acknowledging these hidden struggles can we begin to offer the kind of support that truly makes a difference.

https://www.americansurveycenter.org/newsletter/is-marriage-better-for-men/

https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/staying-sane-inside-insanity/202204/is-marriage-a-bad-deal-for-women