This historic Wild West-era hotel is closing its doors in New Mexico. Here’s why

NEW MEXICO (KRQE) – A northern New Mexico town is losing a significant tourist attraction. Known for housing infamous outlaws, the historic St. James Hotel in Cimarron is closing its doors in two weeks.

It’s a place full of history from the Wild West dating back to 1870 when Henry Lambert first purchased the property starting it off as a small eatery and parlor. Cimarron’s St. James Hotel housed infamous outlaws like Jesse James, Bill the Kid, Annie Oakley, and other figures like Buffalo Bill.

It’s still a big tourism draw, but that may not last much longer. The St. James Hotel recently announced they are closing its doors for business on September 16. “Shock absolute shock because for the employees of course and this can’t be happening we knew eventually it might because it was for sale,” said Yvonne O’Brien.

The owners declined an interview but in a statement, they said the property is “on the market for interested buyers who are committed to preserving its unique legacy.”

The hotel announced its closure on Facebook, racking up thousands of reactions and hundreds of comments. “It’s devastating it’s a special place for everybody in this community and everybody that comes to Cimarron travels through to go to Eagle Nest, Angel Fire they want to stop at the historic St James Hotel,” said Jean Sitzberger.

Locals say the hotel is special and this closure could take a toll on Cimarron.

While the hotel may be closing, many hope a new buyer could help write a new chapter. The current owners have had the property since 2009. For now, they say the plan is to close the property indefinitely.

Below is the full statement from the current owners of the St. James Hotel:

“The St. James Hotel in Cimarron, New Mexico, will be closing its doors on September 17, 2024. The historic hotel, a cherished symbol of Western tradition, is currently on the market for interested buyers who are committed to preserving its unique legacy. The Funk family, who have lovingly owned and stewarded the property since 2009, are grateful for their time with the St. James and believe it is time to pass this iconic piece of history to its next caretakers.”

–Jennifer Callahan, Attorney for the Funk Family, Owners of St. James Hotel

For the latest news, weather, sports, and streaming video, head to KTSM 9 News.