Open in App
  • Local
  • U.S.
  • Election
  • Politics
  • Crime
  • Sports
  • Lifestyle
  • Education
  • Real Estate
  • Newsletter
  • Axios Twin Cities

    Here's what a Trump-Harris matchup could mean for Minnesota's swing state status

    By Torey Van Oot,

    2 days ago

    Minnesota's 2024 race still looks competitive — even after President Biden dropped out and endorsed Vice President Harris — operatives on both sides of the aisle tell Axios.

    The big picture : Growing concerns about Biden's age and popularity were central to the Trump campaign's case that they could flip Minnesota's presidential vote for the first time since 1972.


    • Democrats' rapid consolidation behind Harris has neutralized the party's biggest vulnerability and revitalized the race, Axios' Zachary Basu writes.

    Yes, but: National and swing state polls suggest a Trump-Harris matchup would still be close .

    Catch up fast: Buoyed by polls and shifting election forecasts , the Trump campaign has recently signaled plans to try to win the DFL-controlled state the former president lost by just 45,000 votes in 2016.

    What they're saying: Minnesota Republicans say the shake-up doesn't change the elements they need to win: a fired-up GOP electorate, a divided Democratic base, and strong third-party campaigns.

    • "It's game on," Jennifer DeJournett, president of the Minnesota-based GOP firm Ballot Box Strategies, told Axios on Monday. "It's going to be a function of who has the best turnout operation on the ground."

    Between the lines: Republicans say Harris still carries Biden's baggage on issues they think favor the GOP, such as the economy, immigration, and questions over Biden's fitness for office.

    Reality check: Minnesota Democrats still have significant structural advantages, including control of state government, a statewide population heavily concentrated in the deep blue metro, and a large campaign cash edge .

    • The Biden campaign — which Harris has assumed control of — announced Minnesota hires months ago and the state party already has 25 campaign offices and dozens of paid organizers doing voter outreach.

    The other side: Democrats, too, say the fundamentals of the race remain the same. They still see it as a referendum on Trump and his record on issues like abortion and LGBTQ rights.

    • DFL Party chair Ken Martin predicts that Minnesotans would again "show up in force … to reject [Trump's] extremism."

    The intrigue: Democrats point to record-breaking fundraising — including in Minnesota — after the switch as a sign that a ticket led by Harris will motivate voters.

    • "This isn't a candidate we're pulling off the bench who hasn't been campaigning," Martin said on Sunday.

    What we're watching : Whether Trump follows through with the promised resources that strategists say is required to move the needle.

    • His stated plan for eight field offices would be the biggest Minnesota investment by a Republican presidential candidate in 20 years, said Brian McClung, a veteran of former GOP Gov. Tim Pawlenty's presidential campaign.
    • Minnesota Republican Party chair David Hann told Axios that high enthusiasm among GOP voters and the party's recent climb out of debt puts it in a good position to capitalize on that help.

    The bottom line: We're still not a swing state. If Minnesota flips, it probably means the blue wall has crumbled and Trump has achieved a "victory of historic proportions," McClung notes.

    • But even if he doesn't succeed, Republican efforts could force Democrats to spend more time and energy here, diverting resources from even more competitive states.

    The math and the path: Factors to watch in Minnesota

    Here are five factors that will influence Trump's success, based on a dozen conversations with GOP and DFL strategists and officials:

    1. Voter drop-off: Trump's math gets better if Democrats and independents disillusioned with Harris and the Biden administration stay home — including DFL primary voters who cast an "uncommitted" ballot to protest the Israel-Hamas War.

    2. "Rural roar:" Increasing vote totals throughout GOP-leaning parts of Greater Minnesota — including in the "L" formed by the First and Seventh Congressional Districts — is key to closing the margin, DeJournett says.

    • What to watch: She's working to persuade rural Republicans to vote early and by mail — a strategy Trump himself now embraces— to allow more resources to shift to swing voters later on.
    • Plus: Republican energy following the attempt on Trump's life could also help motivate his base in those areas.

    3. Suburban shift: Trump also needs to regain the suburban ground he lost to Biden in 2020, including in the south metro bellwether of Dakota County, operatives argue.

    • Pawlenty, who ran for president in 2012, told Axios that Trump will "need to over-perform in first-ring suburbs while clawing back support" from others.

    4. Issue shake-up: Abortion drove voters to the polls in 2022, benefitting Democrats. Harris could bring that issue back to the forefront.

    5. Third-party rise: In 2016 when Trump narrowly lost the state, third-party candidates pulled about 9% of the vote. In 2020, when Biden won by 7, third parties captured less than 3%.

    • Results from a November ballot with Robert F. Kennedy Jr., Jill Stein, and Cornel West will look more like 2016, GOP communications consultant Preya Samsundar, an RNC alum, predicts.
    Expand All
    Comments / 0
    Add a Comment
    YOU MAY ALSO LIKE
    Most Popular newsMost Popular

    Comments / 0