Court Dismisses Lawsuit Claiming Finger Was Found In Salad At Mount Kisco Eatery

The lawsuit, filed against Rye Brook-based Chop't Creative Salad Company LLC by Fairfield County resident Allison Cozzi of Greenwich, was dismissed by the Westchester County Supreme Court on Thursday, July 11.

Cozzi, who brought the suit against Chop't in November, claimed she found part of a severed finger inside her meal bought at a Chop't location in Northern Westchester County at 53 South Moger Ave. in Mount Kisco.

According to the lawsuit, Cozzi purchased a salad at the Chop't location in April 2023. Shortly after she began eating it, she realized that she was chewing on a part of a human finger that had allegedly been mixed in with the salad.

The complaint had also alleged that earlier in the same day, a manager working at the eatery had been chopping arugula when she chopped off a portion of her left pointer finger.

The manager then left the restaurant and was hospitalized, the complaint said, also detailing that the arugula she had been chopping was left on the service line and served to customers, including Cozzi.

After the incident, the Westchester County Department of Health investigated and eventually issued a $900 ticket to Chop't. This ticket was not contested or appealed by the company, and was paid, according to the lawsuit complaint.

As a result of the incident, the complaint said that Cozzi experienced shock, panic attacks, migraines, traumatic stress and anxiety, nausea, vomiting, and more.

Because the lawsuit was "discontinued with prejudice," Cozzi will not be able to bring it back to court.

to follow Daily Voice Mt. Kisco and receive free news updates.