20% of Chicago's Murders Missing From FBI Data Demonstrating Inaccuracies in Crime Reporting System

Experts raise concerns about discrepancies in FBI crime figures due to Chicago inaccuracies, impact on national crime statistics

Photo byScreen Capture/Youtube Video [Creator]

CHICAGO - The FBI recently released a report indicating that violent crime decreased by about 3% in 2023 compared to the previous year, with murder rates dropping nearly 12%. However, concerns about the accuracy of these figures have surfaced, with a crime data expert suggesting that the statistics might not reflect the full scope of crime across the country due to gaps in data collection.

Sean Kennedy, executive director of the Coalition for Law Order and Safety (CLOS), expressed concerns over the FBI's crime data, calling attention to errors and inconsistencies in the figures. According to Kennedy, the discrepancies stem from the FBI's ongoing transition to the National Incident-Based Reporting System (NIBRS), a new and more detailed data collection method.

NIBRS requires multiple data points for every offense, providing a richer set of data than the legacy Uniform Crime Reporting (UCR) system. While this new system aims to offer a clearer picture of crime trends, the transition has been difficult for many of the over 19,000 law enforcement agencies in the United States. In 2021, the FBI mandated that all agencies report crime data through NIBRS, but about 40% of agencies were unable to comply, citing resource constraints.

As a result, the FBI relaxed the mandate in 2022, allowing agencies to submit data through either NIBRS or the legacy UCR system. Despite this adjustment, only 73% of law enforcement agencies used NIBRS in 2023, while 12% continued with the older methods, and the remainder did not submit any data. To address this shortfall, the FBI relies on estimates to account for missing data, but Kennedy warns that this estimation process introduces further inaccuracies.

"All estimates are inherently off. The FBI is using estimates to arrive at a more accurate figure than raw reporting totals, but that doesn't mean they're necessarily more or less wrong," Kennedy said. "It just means they're still flawed."

Kennedy highlighted a specific example of data discrepancies, pointing to Chicago’s 2023 homicide numbers. According to the FBI, Chicago recorded 499 homicides that year. However, the Chicago Police Department reported 617 homicides. Kennedy notes that the FBI may have received incomplete data from Chicago, either due to reporting gaps or the difficulty of complying with NIBRS requirements.

"That is 118 missing murders," Kennedy said. "The FBI may have received data for only part of the year, or they made a mistake in inputting the information. Either way, they're guessing what the numbers might have been for the remainder of the year."

Kennedy emphasized that the transition to NIBRS, while a step forward, has created challenges for law enforcement agencies. He argues that many local police departments lack the resources to comply with the system, which requires extensive data collection for each incident.

The Chicago Police Department declined to comment directly on the discrepancy, instead referring to a January news release that noted a 12.9% drop in homicides in 2023 compared to the previous year.

The FBI, for its part, insists that NIBRS was developed in collaboration with local and state law enforcement agencies. The bureau states that 94.3% of the U.S. population was covered by crime data submitted in 2023, either through NIBRS or the legacy system.

"We do have a very robust system to capture the vast majority of data, but no system is 100% accurate," an FBI official said. "We're consistently working with law enforcement agencies to ensure the transition to NIBRS is as smooth as possible."

To account for the 5.7% of the population not covered by submitted crime data, the FBI uses a statistical process to extrapolate trends based on the available data. This method, the bureau argues, allows it to provide a true national representation of crime rates.

"There is a statistical process applied to reported data from about 85% of agencies to make it a national representation," the official explained. "We're constantly working to improve the system and release the data to the public more quickly."

Kennedy acknowledges that NIBRS is an improvement over the previous system, but he believes local police departments need more support to comply with the new requirements. He suggests that federal, state, and local grants could help provide the necessary resources for full participation in NIBRS.

"NIBRS is a good system, but it was implemented without proper consultation and without ensuring local authorities had the resources to comply," Kennedy said. "As a result, the 2021 data is almost useless. It's filled with errors, and we can't be certain how bad the crime situation was that year because of the gaps in reporting."

Despite these concerns, Kennedy sees the transition to NIBRS as a positive development in the long run. He argues that the current debate over data accuracy is a sign of increased transparency in crime reporting.

"The fact that we can now identify discrepancies like the missing Chicago homicides is a testament to the progress we've made in crime data transparency," Kennedy said. "This level of scrutiny wouldn't have been possible 20 or 50 years ago. Today, we're discussing methodology and data inputs, which is a step forward."

The FBI is working to ensure that its crime data is as accurate as possible, with officials emphasizing that their sole goal is to provide the public with the best available information. The bureau says it hopes to release crime data more frequently in the future, potentially on a monthly basis, to offer a more up-to-date picture of national crime trends.

Kennedy remains hopeful that with better support and resources, local law enforcement agencies will be able to fully comply with NIBRS and provide more accurate data. "Everyone involved is trying their best," he said. "But there needs to be a system in place that ensures local agencies can meet the reporting requirements, and we're not there yet."