Yelp reveals top spots to get pizza in New York City

NEW YORK (PIX11) — For many tourists, iconic attractions like the Empire State Building and the Statue of Liberty are must-see stops, but no visit to the Big Apple would be complete without enjoying a slice of pizza.

Whether you are in the mood for New York-style pizza, known for its hand-tossed thin crust and large foldable slices, or wood-fired artisan pizza, there’s nothing like a good slice on a hot summer day.

The sheer number of pizzerias in New York City can be overwhelming when trying to choose where to go. Yelp staff recently identified restaurants with a high concentration of reviews mentioning pizza and ranked those spots using several factors, including the total volume and ratings of reviews.

Here are the top pizza spots in New York City, according to Yelp.

The Bronx

Kingsbridge Social Club

With intriguing menu options like The Cherry Bomb pizza — featuring meatballs, bacon, hot cherry peppers, mozzarella, and San Marzano tomatoes — the Kingsbridge Social Club at 3625 Kingsbridge Ave. in Kingsbridge is a spot to check out. Membership is not required to dine in.

Brooklyn

Dough Vale

Located at 330 South 3rd St. in Williamsburg, the Dough Vale is known for its low-gluten dough, made of five different types of flour (Semolina, Rice Flour, Soy Flour, Spelt Flour, and Corn Flour). A notable item on the menu to consider is the U Zu Nitto , a half-pizza/half-calzone.

L’Industrie Pizzeria

Based at 254 South 2nd St. in Williamsburg, L’Industrie Pizzeria offers both whole pies and pizza by the slice (in-store only). While some shudder at the thought of it, adventurous pizza lovers should try the Fig Jam and Bacon Pie.

Manhattan

Carnegie Pizza

Located just minutes away from bustling Times Square, this cozy pizzeria offers an array of wallet-friendly slices perfect for a quick bite on the move. Whole pies and gluten-free pizzas are also available.

Nolita Pizza

Boasting pizzas made with locally sourced produce to imported Italian specialties, Nolita Pizza is a top destination for authentic Italian cuisine. The restaurant is located at 68 Kenmare St. in Lower Manhattan.

Pop’s Pizza

Searching for a variety of toppings? This local establishment offers a wide range of items from traditional margherita to ones topped with pepperoni, jalapeño, and chili-infused honey. Check out the extensive menu at 301 West 57th St., just steps from Central Park.

Song’E Napule Pizzeria & Trattoria

Usually, a restaurant that claims to have the best pizza in NYC might raise some eyebrows, but the reviews so far have been excellent. Song’E Napule has several locations, including at 146 West Houston St. in Greenwich Village and 464 Amsterdam Ave. on the Upper East Side.

Sottocasa Pizzeria

Hailing from Napoli and Piacenza, owners Elena and Matteo originally ran a restaurant on Elba Island in Tuscany for five years. Now, they are bringing Italian culture and food to Harlem, serving authentic Neapolitan pizza at 227 Malcolm X Blvd.

Stone Bridge Artisanal Pizza

At Stone Bridge, diners can indulge in farm-to-table artisanal pizzas with crunchy crusts. The restaurant also offers six frozen artisanal pizza squares that you can heat up in the office or at home. The restaurant is located at 16 East 41st St. in Midtown.

Vito’s Slices and Ices

Does pizza made with fresh ingredients from local farmers’ markets and house-made Italian ice sound appetizing? Look no further! Vito’s Slices and Ices at 464 Ninth Ave., near Hudson Yards, is a perfect spot for a quick bite and a cold treat to cool you down.

Queens

Philomena’s Sunnyside Queens

A quick glance at the menu might leave some customers confused, with pizzas named Spicy Mikey, Ninja Turtle, and Raging Bull, but rest assured, Philomena’s is a top spot for all pizza lovers. Located at 41-16 Queens Blvd. in Sunnyside, the restaurant boasts a rating of 4.6 stars on Yelp.

Ben Mitchell is a digital content producer from Vermont who has covered both local and international news since 2021. He joined PIX11 in 2024. See more of his work here .

For the latest news, weather, sports, and streaming video, head to PIX11.