Starbucks Customer Goes Viral For Sharing The Chain’s 'Dramatic' Rewards Policy—Expired Stars Can Only Be Replaced 'Once In A Lifetime': ‘This Is Hilarious’

In a recent Reddit post , a Starbucks customer highlighted an interaction with customer service that left users of the Starbucks subreddit baffled—and amused.

Did you know that your Starbucks rewards points expire? And did you know that you can recover those expired reward points? It’s true—but there’s one major stipulation. According to a Starbucks live agent, stars can only be replaced “once in a lifetime.” Guess they’re a lot like love in that way. Find all the details below.

Posts from the starbucks
community on Reddit

Reddit user shares “wild” Starbucks customer service interaction

A Reddit post titled “Expired stars can only be replaced once in a lifetime?!,” quickly garnered attention last week for revealing a little-known policy about the replacement of expired rewards stars.

The original post simply exclaimed, “Wild,” and included a screenshot of a conversation with a live Starbucks agent. The agent informed the customer, “Just to inform you expired stars can only be replaced once in a lifetime.” This revelation struck many as both amusing and perplexing.

One commenter wrote, “This is hilarious lowkey.” The original poser responded, “It’s so dramatic and for what.”

Another comment says, “Was not aware you could even get expired ones replaced lol,” to which another user cheekily responded, “You can in this lifetime! But only once.”

The post opened up a broader discussion about the nature and effectiveness of rewards programs. One user questioned the need for stars to expire at all: "I have no idea why stars should ever expire in the first place. I mean, other than greed." Another commenter elaborated on the strategic reasoning behind such policies:

"Rewards programs are to make sure that people who spend money keep spending money, they are NOT meant as a money-saving gift to customers. Letting you keep stars indefinitely would defeat the purpose of having them. It creates urgency for you to return to the store if the stars expire. It also is to dissuade people’s savings/hoarding instincts to see how many they can get."

The discussion also revealed that some customers were unaware of the expiration policy altogether. One shocked user exclaimed, "Stars expire???" to which another replied, "It's their way of trying to make you addicted to going to Starbucks."

Beyond the absurdity of the interaction, the post highlights a common frustration among consumers: the often convoluted and restrictive nature of rewards programs . While these programs are designed to foster customer loyalty, they can sometimes backfire when customers feel the rules are overly complicated or stingy. This particular Starbucks policy, with its dramatic "once in a lifetime" replacement rule, struck many as both funny and a perfect example of corporate overreach in customer loyalty programs. For Starbucks, and others with similar policies, it might be time to brew up some changes that balance corporate interests with genuine customer satisfaction.

READ MORE: Sephora Is Making A Major Change To Their Rewards Program And Fans Are Furious: ‘We Ride At Dawn’