Welsh response to Covid ‘hampered by undue complexity’

The Welsh government’s response to the Covid pandemic was “hampered by undue complexity,” a public inquiry has found.

In its first report into preparedness for a pandemic, the UK Covid-19 Inquiry has branded the system in Wales “labyrinthine” with failed opportunities to create a coherent structure.

Opposition parties have branded the report “damning” and say it “exposes serious and significant failings on the part of the Labour Welsh government”.

Vaughan Gething, the outgoing First Minister of Wales, has said the report will be studied in detail and motions brought to the Senedd to address shortcomings.

An opportunity to create a coherent and, therefore, dynamic system in Wales had been hampered by undue complexity

The report said: “For an administration that prided itself on its efficiency of movement because of its relative lack of scale, and which had described itself as operating, effectively, ‘under one roof’, the reality did not match the rhetoric.

“The system was labyrinthine.

“The inquiry was not persuaded by the mitigation offered by (Dr Andrew Goodall permanent secretary to the Welsh government) that it made more sense to those within the system than those outside of it.

“An opportunity to create a coherent and, therefore, dynamic system in Wales had been hampered by undue complexity.”

The report also said the chief scientific adviser for Wales and the chief scientific adviser for health in Wales were “not central to pandemic preparedness and resilience”.

While health services are devolved to the Welsh government, Mark Drakeford , the former first minister of Wales, told the inquiry in February that before the first lockdown he believed the UK government would be in charge of the country’s pandemic response.

Responding to the report, Andrew RT Davies MS, leader of the Welsh Conservatives, said: “It’s abundantly clear from this report that Labour ministers were out of their depth and had no idea of the state of Wales’ pandemic readiness.

“The evidence heard revealed the Labour Welsh Government to be wholly unprepared and lacking a plan.

“We need a Wales-specific Covid inquiry to rectify these blatant errors.”

The Welsh government has previously rejected calls for a specific inquiry for the country.

Mabon ap Gwynfor MS, Plaid Cymru spokesperson for health and social care, said: “This is a damning report which exposes serious and significant failings on the part of the Labour Welsh government.

A picture of over-complex structures, lack of accountability, important work left unfinished and a general feeling of unwarranted over-confidence in preparedness plans is laid out in stark terms by (inquiry chairwoman) Baroness Hallett

“The report will make difficult reading for Covid-bereaved families and our thoughts are with them today.

“A picture of over-complex structures, lack of accountability, important work left unfinished and a general feeling of unwarranted over-confidence in preparedness plans is laid out in stark terms by (inquiry chairwoman) Baroness Hallett.

“It is of deep concern to read that some of the lessons have not been learned.”

He called on the Welsh government to “admit to its significant failings” and to implement the recommendations made in the report.

In a statement shared by the Welsh government, Mr Gething, the First Minister, said he welcomed the report.

“The publication is an important moment for Welsh families bereaved by Covid-19, and for the frontline staff who worked so hard during the pandemic to keep us all safe,” he said.

“The report highlights many recommendations relevant to Welsh Government and our partners.

“We will now study the report in detail and respond fully to the inquiry on each of these.”

The Senedd Covid-19 Inquiry Special Purpose Committee will now scrutinise the report and propose to the Senedd by motion any gaps identified in the inquiry’s report.