Taylor Cole — Check Out Our 8 Favorite Romance Movies Starring the Hallmark Sweetheart We Love

Taylor Cole is no stranger to Hallmark — As a matter of fact, the 40-year-old Los Angeles actress made her debut on the network in 2016 alongside Andrew Walker in Appetite for Love . Since then, she’s starred in countless Hallmark romances and mysteries, famously bringing to life the character of Ruby Herring in the Ruby Herring Mysteries film series.

Andrew Walker Is Hallmark Royalty: 23 of His Best Movies, Ranked

Although we haven’t seen her on the network since 2023, Cole hinted on social media that her return to Hallmark could be in the near future when she shared a photo to Instagram from Vancouver, featuring a wrapped present emoji in the caption. Could this mean a bit of Hallmark holiday magic is in the works? After all, she replied to a comment asking if we’d see her on the screen with, “should hear good news soon ❤️.” Fingers crossed!

While we wait for Cole’s return to the channel, take a look at our ranking of her eight best Hallmark movies from over the years.

Our 8 favorite Taylor Cole Hallmark movies, ranked

8. Long Lost Christmas (2022)

When Hayley learns her mother has a brother, she sets out to find him and give her recently widowed mom the surprise of an extended family she knows she’s always wanted. Also starring Hallmark hunk Benjamin Ayres.

Benjamin Ayres: 11 of Our Favorite Movies Starring the Hallmark Hunk

7. My Summer Prince (2016)

When a top PR consultant is hired to remedy the partying ways of a prince and heir to the throne, she falls ill and her assistant is forced to take her place — but what happens when she starts falling for the royal?

MUST-READ: Hallmark Hunks! 20 Leading Men Who Bring Our Favorite Love Stories to Life

6. The Art of Us (2017)

Harper, who has her heart set on a tenured position at Boston College, has the showcase artist of her gallery fall through despite the exhibit making or breaking her chances. However, her new dog walker, who just so happens to be a talented painter, just might be the artist she’s looking for.

5. Falling for You (2018)

A radio station manager ropes in a visiting business man consumed by work to participate in the fundraiser she’s organizing to save the station. Also starring Tyler Hynes.

Tyler Hynes Movies: 16 of His Best Hallmark Romances Guaranteed to Steal Your Heart

4. Appetite for Love (2016)

When Mina’s job sends her to her hometown to convince a restaurant owner to sell, she’s shocked to discover that it’s now in the hands of her ex-boyfriend, played by Andrew Walker.

MUST-READ: Hallmark Star Andrew Walker Shares His Holiday Traditions & Behind-the-Scenes Secrets in This Tell-All Q&A!

3. Matching Hearts (2020)

When a matchmaker gets the opportunity to pair off a handsome, single entrepreneur, she doesn’t expect to fall for him herself. Also starring Ryan Paevey.

MUST-READ: Swoon Alert! The Top 14 Ryan Paevey Hallmark Movies You *Must* See

2. Pumpkin Everything (2022)

When Amy’s grandfather breaks his wrist, she returns to her hometown to man his pumpkin-themed store — and her high school best friend (Corey Sevier) happens to be running the place.

MUST-READ: Corey Sevier’s Most Swoon-Worthy Hallmark Movies and Shows, Ranked

1 . Aloha Heart (2023)

Cole plays a conservationist in Hawaii for her friend’s wedding who finds herself helping a hotel manager make his family’s establishment more sustainable.

Want more Hallmark stories? Click through below!

Are You a ‘Yellowstone’ Fan? Then Check Out These 7 Hallmark Films for Your Next Movie Night

Jen Lilley: Read About the Actress and Singer Who Has Left Her Mark on the Hallmark World

Catrick Mahomes Is Hitting the Silver Screen! Learn All About His Hallmark Debut

20 Hallmark Actresses Who Bring Our Favorite Stories to Life