Mary Janes Are Always in My Shoe Rotation—Here's How I'm Styling Them for Fall

This may be a bold take, but no fashion era has shined this bright since the '90s. There's no way I'll look back on the early 2020s and say, "What was I thinking wearing that outfit?" We've ditched the colored skinny jeans and overly studded belts of the 2010s and embraced '90s-inspired ensembles. Head-to-toe denim looks, socks with Mary Janes, and monochromatic outfits are set to make a return this fall—just ask my fellow editor, Aniyah Morinia. When I asked her what I should buy for fall, she named one key item: Franco Sarto's Tinsley Mary Jane shoes. They're versatile, timeless, and fit into that '90s aesthetic we all strive for. If you want to achieve Morinia's effortlessly cool style for fall, start with these classic shoes. See how she styles her favorite colorways below.

"Nothing says fall like a Canadian tuxedo! It's basically my uniform this time of year, and like all uniforms, the formula can get stale really fast. To spice things up, I always rely on exciting shoes and accessories. These leopard-print flats play into two huge trends that I can't get enough of: animal print and Mary Janes. The print is loud enough to get compliments from strangers on the street but subtle enough to take on the role of a neutral when necessary." — Aniyah Morinia, editor

Franco Sarto

Tinsley Mary Jane Flat in Leopard Print

$115

"I'm going to go on record and say that red is no longer a trending color for fall—it's a staple. Expect to see it year after year. I love how red and gray look when styled together, so I opted for this gray maxi dress with a necktie to give that fall feeling without having to add layers. The patent leather on the shoes adds a nice touch of elegance without making the look feel too formal. We're still in the pre-fall phase, so this pairing felt weather-appropriate and perfect for strolls around the city." — Morinia

Franco Sarto

Tinsley Mary Jane Flat in Gothic Red Patent Faux Leather

$115

Shop More Colorways at Macy’s and FrancoSarto.com

Franco Sarto

Tinsley Mary Jane Flat in Black Faux Leather

$115

Franco Sarto

Tinsley Mary Jane Flat in Silver Faux Leather

$115

Franco Sarto

Tinsley Mary Jane Flat in Beige Faux Leather

$115

Franco Sarto

Tinsley Mary Jane Flat in Bronze Faux Leather

$115