For all that streamers and cable channels love to boast about how much everyone loves their brand-new shows, a lot of us just enjoy rewatching stuff we’ve seen before, or catching up on well-loved older shows we missed during their time. The streaming era has made it easier than ever for people to access older TV while also narrowing the list of what’s available— and by extension narrowing the range of what kinds of shows end up enduring in popularity long after their finales have aired. For every Sopranos or Twilight Zone there are tons of other shows that were just as popular at the time but never had as much lasting impact.