"Navigating Home Buying vs. Renting: The Best U.S. Cities for 2024"

Photo byAssociated Press

As the debate between renting and buying a home intensifies, 2024 has unveiled intriguing insights into which U.S. cities offer the best financial sense for each option. A recent study by Clever Real Estate challenges the conventional wisdom that buying a home is inherently a better investment than renting. With average home prices surging 39% faster than rent prices since 2019, this notion is under scrutiny.

The New Real Estate Reality

According to the study, the price-to-rent ratios across the 50 most populous U.S. metros reveal that renting is often the more cost-effective choice. In fact, renting is cheaper than buying in 32 of these metros when analyzed through the price-to-rent ratio lens. When considering the full spectrum of homeownership costs—including principal, interest, taxes, and insurance—monthly rent outstrips mortgage payments in 48 out of 50 cities surveyed.

Despite the rising costs of homeownership, there are still a few markets where buying a home remains a viable option. However, such markets are becoming increasingly rare.

The Hidden Costs of Homeownership

While many Americans regard renting as a financial pitfall—nearly 60% view it as throwing money away—homeownership is not without its challenges. Homeowners often face unexpected expenses, with annual maintenance and repairs potentially costing up to $18,000. Additionally, the time investment is substantial, with the average homeowner spending nearly 600 hours per year on upkeep.

These factors contribute to significant stress, with over a third of homeowners admitting they’d feel less stressed if they rented instead. This sentiment is echoed by more than one-quarter of homeowners who are considering a return to renting.

Decoding the Price-To-Rent Ratio

Housing experts use the price-to-rent ratio to gauge whether buying or renting is more advantageous in specific areas. This ratio is calculated by dividing the median home price by the median annual rent. A ratio of 15 or below typically indicates that buying is more favorable, while a ratio of 21 or above suggests renting is the smarter choice. Between 16 and 20, renting may still be preferable, but individual circumstances should be considered.

Given the current price-to-rent ratios, buying a home is financially advantageous in only 18 of the top 50 U.S. metros.

Top Cities for Buyers: Cleveland Leads the Way

Among the cities studied, Cleveland stands out with the lowest price-to-rent ratio of 11, coupled with a median home price of just $187,413. This makes it a compelling choice for homebuyers, particularly given the lifestyle benefits of homeownership in the area. Geoffrey Hoffman, a local real estate agent, notes, “In Cleveland, the benefits of homeownership often outweigh renting, especially for families looking for more stability.”

Cleveland’s affordability extends to other Rust Belt cities such as Pittsburgh, Chicago, St. Louis, Detroit, Cincinnati, and Indianapolis. Additionally, Southern cities like New Orleans, Memphis, and Birmingham offer some of the country’s most affordable home prices, making them top contenders for potential buyers.

Renting Prevails in High-Cost Western Cities

On the West Coast, where home prices soar, renting becomes the more pragmatic option. San Jose tops the list with a staggering price-to-rent ratio of 37.6, reflecting its median home value of over $1.5 million. Despite the high rent of $3,331—one of the highest in the nation—renting remains more financially sensible.

Julie Wyss, a San Jose-based agent, explains, “San Jose’s high housing prices are driven by the influx of tech professionals with substantial salaries. For many, renting is a more viable option until the housing market stabilizes.”

Other Western cities where renting outweighs buying include San Francisco, Los Angeles, Seattle, Salt Lake City, San Diego, Portland, Denver, and Austin.

Conclusion

As the housing market continues to evolve, prospective buyers and renters alike should carefully consider local market conditions. Whether buying or renting is the best option will depend largely on individual circumstances and regional trends, underscoring the importance of staying informed and adaptable in today’s real estate landscape.