Study Reveals Ethical Dilemmas Teachers Face with AI in K-12 Education

Photo byPhoto by Steve Johnson on Unsplash

A new report from the USC Center for Generative AI and Society examines how teachers' gender and comfort with technology influence their adoption of artificial intelligence (AI) in classrooms. The study, "AI in K-12 Classrooms: Ethical Considerations and Lessons Learned," surveyed 248 K-12 educators to understand their ethical views on using AI technologies like ChatGPT.

The research reveals that nearly half of the surveyed teachers are open to using AI, with over a third intending to use it regularly. Gender differences were observed, with female teachers favouring rule-based (deontological) perspectives, while male teachers were more concerned with the consequences of AI (outcome-based views). Additionally, teachers' confidence in and anxiety about technology impacted their willingness to integrate AI into their teaching.

The report highlights the importance of ethical considerations in AI adoption. Teachers are grappling with moral dilemmas, such as whether to prioritize strict rules or outcomes when using AI in education. The study aligns with the broader goals of the USC Center for Generative AI and Society, which aims to explore AI's impact on education and society and foster critical thinking skills among students.

The USC Center also introduces its AI Fellows Program and emphasizes the potential of AI to enhance educational processes. It suggests that rather than restricting AI use, educators should rethink teaching strategies to incorporate AI to improve education. This includes using AI to assist with brainstorming, critique essays, and develop critical thinking skills.

Overall, the report advocates for a thoughtful integration of AI in education, ensuring that such technologies support rather than replace human interaction and emotional aspects of teaching.