Tiny Lakefront Gem Scores Big: Sells for 20% Over Asking Price

Photo byFront Door Photography

At just 824 square feet, this tiny lakefront home offers all the charm of an apartment but with a location that makes a lasting impression. Perched on the serene shores of Lower Mount Glen Lake in West Milford, the property recently made waves in the market.

A Hot Market for Lake Living

Originally listed at $279,900, this one-bedroom retreat drew in eight offers and ultimately sold for $325,000—20% over its asking price. According to Jennifer Ellis of Coldwell Banker Realty, a specialist in lakefront properties, “A move-in ready lake house for under $300,000 is very rare unless it needs a lot of work. The one bedroom kept the price low.”

Cozy Living with Scenic Views

This home’s open floor plan maximizes space while offering lake views from the kitchen and direct access to a lakefront deck. The living room features a rustic stone wood-burning fireplace, creating a cozy atmosphere perfect for lakeside living. Additional features include an office space, an updated bathroom, and a 9-foot by 11-foot bedroom with a walk-in closet—ideal for those seeking a minimalist yet comfortable lifestyle.

A Lifestyle of Outdoor Recreation

Lower Mount Glen Lake spans 15 acres, making it an ideal spot for kayaking, fishing, and swimming. The community also offers a beach equipped with volleyball courts and a playground. For nature enthusiasts, Norvin Green State Forest is nearby, and Route 23 provides convenient access for commuters or weekend getaways.