How One Florida Condo And Tallahassee Set Florida's Condo "Terminations" On Fire

One Building Destroyed the Florida Condo MarketPhoto byOCMM

As Florida's aging condominiums face structural and financial challenges, associations increasingly opt for termination and redevelopment, often against the wishes of some owners.

Fort Lauderdale, FL – Recently, Florida has witnessed a growing trend of historic condominium terminations, leading to the demolition of aging buildings and the rise of new developments. This phenomenon has sparked controversy, particularly among owners who oppose the termination of their associations. The driving forces behind this trend are multifaceted, involving legal, financial, and safety considerations.

A growing number of historic condominiums in Florida are being torn down to make way for new developments, leaving long-time owners facing an uncertain future. The trend, driven by aging buildings and skyrocketing maintenance costs, has sparked controversy as associations terminate their condominium status, often against the wishes of some owners.

The termination process allows a supermajority of condo owners - typically 80% or more - to agree to end the condominium association and sell the entire property. This provides a potential windfall for owners, as the land is often worth far more than the individual units. However, the process has also faced backlash from residents who wish to preserve their homes and communities.

The Legal Framework
Section 718.117 of the Florida Statutes governs the process of terminating a condominium association in Florida. This statute outlines the procedures and requirements for termination, which have evolved through legislative amendments. The 2017 amendments, in particular, made it more challenging and costly to terminate a condominium association. These changes were aimed at ensuring that terminations are in the public's best interest and that homeowners are treated fairly.

The dissolution of a condominium association in Florida can happen for several reasons. One common scenario involves financial difficulties, such as unpaid assessments or significant maintenance costs. In other cases, disputes among unit owners or a lack of quorum at association meetings can lead to a breakdown in governance.

The trend of condominium terminations is not unique to Florida. Other states, such as California and New York, are also experiencing a rise in terminations driven by similar factors. However, Florida's unique combination of aging buildings, rising maintenance costs, new condo laws, and developer demand has created a perfect storm for condominium terminations.

Factors Driving Terminations
Several factors contribute to the increasing interest in terminating older condominiums:

• Aging Infrastructure and Safety Concerns: The tragic collapse of the Champlain Towers South in Surfside in 2021 highlighted the risks associated with aging condominium buildings. This disaster prompted many associations to reevaluate the long-term costs and risks of maintaining older properties. Structural safety concerns often outweigh the feasibility of repairs, making termination and redevelopment a more viable alternative.
• Economic Considerations: The cost of repairing and maintaining aging buildings can be exorbitant. In many cases, the cost of repairs exceeds the market value of the units after repairs are completed. This economic waste makes termination a more attractive option for associations facing financial strain.
• Developer Interest: Developers are increasingly eyeing older condominiums as attractive redevelopment opportunities. Prime real estate locations and the rising cost of maintaining aging buildings make these properties appealing for new, high-value structures. Developers often engage in bulk purchases, buying out large portions of units to gain controlling interest and push through termination plans.

Why The Controversy
While redevelopment can bring economic benefits to a community, it can also have negative consequences for some unit owners. In many cases, owners who have lived in their condominiums for years may be forced to relocate, often at a significant financial cost. Additionally, the demolition of historic buildings can result in a loss of cultural heritage and a decline in property values for nearby homes.

Critics argue that termination votes are sometimes manipulated by developers who buy up units to secure the necessary majority. There are also concerns that lower-income owners are being priced out of their homes as a result.

While termination and redevelopment may seem like a practical solution, it is not without controversy. Many unit owners oppose the termination of their associations for various reasons:

• Loss of Home and Community: For many owners, their condominium units are not just investments but homes and communities. The prospect of losing their homes and being forced to relocate can be distressing.
• Disputes Over Fair Compensation: Owners often dispute the compensation offered by developers for their units. They may feel that the offers do not reflect the true value of their properties, leading to legal battles and delays in the termination process.
• Legal Challenges: Recent court rulings have added complexity to the termination process. For example, a Florida appeals court ruling in March 2024 upended a condo termination in Miami, marking a major win for the condo owners who fought to block the termination of their association. This ruling has significant implications for developers, lenders, and condo associations statewide.

Forward Together
A combination of safety concerns, economic considerations, and developer interest drives the trend of terminating historic condominiums in Florida. However, this trend is not without its challenges and controversies. As more associations opt for termination and redevelopment, the legal landscape continues to evolve, and the voices of dissenting owners remain a critical part of the conversation.

The ongoing trend of condo terminations in Florida highlights the tension between development and preservation, as well as the potential for legal and ethical conflicts. As more historic properties face the wrecking ball, the debate over how to balance these competing interests is likely to intensify.

We appreciate you taking the time to read this article. Your opinions and ideas mean a lot to us. Please join the conversation and share your thoughts by leaving a comment and hitting the LIKE, SHARE, and FOLLOW buttons. Your engagement is truly appreciated.