Biden Again Has Union Support. But the Unions Look Different This Time.

WASHINGTON — The public image of President Biden’s “Union Joe” persona rests largely on his longtime affiliations with labor unions representing police officers, firefighters and building-trade workers.

But the modern labor movement that gathered Saturday in Philadelphia to endorse Biden’s 2024 reelection campaign is younger and more diverse, and has far more women than the union stereotype Biden has embraced during the decades he has spent building his political identity.

“You think about it as the dude with a cigar, and it’s just not that,” said Randi Weingarten, president of the American Federation of Teachers. “I’m sure there’s still dudes with cigars, but there’s lots and lots and lots of other people in a multigenerational, multiracial cacophony of people that are unified by a zealous fight for a better life.”

While today’s labor movement is demographically more in line with the Democratic Party, increasing the share of young people and people of color means that union members may be less familiar with — and more skeptical about — Biden’s record.

Biden’s campaign and the labor leaders who endorsed it — the AFL-CIO and 17 other unions — celebrated the early backing as a triumph of labor unity for the president. The president appeared before a supportive and energetic audience of about 2,000 union members in Philadelphia, the first rally of his reelection campaign since it started in April.

“I’m the most pro-union president in American history,” Biden told the cheering crowd Saturday, echoing a vow he made during his 2020 campaign. Predicting another victory in 2024, he added: “What I’m really proud about is being reelected the most pro-union president in history.”

The endorsements reflect Biden’s popularity among the unions’ leaders, but large segments of the union membership do not associate him with the union-friendly legislation he has signed into law.

“There is a disconnect between all the Biden-Harris accomplishments and what information is landing on the ground in communities,” said Liz Shuler, president of the AFL-CIO. “It is such an inside-the-Beltway thing to do to talk about policies and talk about legislation and regulations. It’s up to us to decode that and connect the dots back to what is happening in Washington.”

Upon entering office, Biden pledged to be “the most pro-union president you’ve ever seen,” and he has largely delivered on that promise.

During the Philadelphia union rally — officially hosted by the AFL-CIO but with all the trappings of a Biden campaign event —the president ticked through his pro-union accomplishments. Along with the climate, infrastructure and semiconductor manufacturing bills he signed that incentivize companies that employ unionized workers, Biden cited the Butch Lewis Act, which restored the pensions of more than 1 million people whose retirement benefits had been severely reduced because of underfunded multi-employer pension plans.

“That was a big deal,” Biden said. “It was one of the most significant achievements for union workers and retirees in 50 years.”

The Biden administration has made clear that it stands with unionized workers. Jill Biden, the first lady, wore the blue T-shirt of the National Education Association on Saturday. Last weekend, Biden’s education secretary, Miguel Cardona, refused to cross a picket line to give a commencement address at the University of Washington. Vice President Kamala Harris canceled an MTV appearance after Hollywood writers went on strike.

Last month, workers at a school bus factory in Georgia won the first significant organizing election at a facility receiving major federal funding under legislation signed by Biden.

The president has also been far more vocal than his Democratic predecessors in encouraging union organizing. Last year, Biden welcomed to the White House the millennial Amazon and Starbucks organizers who had unionized parts of those companies.

Before he was president, Biden was a regular at Labor Day parades — especially in Pittsburgh, home of the largely male and white steelworker unions that built much of western Pennsylvania, and where he kicked off his 2020 campaign.

That run followed a defection of large numbers of union workers to Donald Trump’s 2016 campaign, which had reoriented the Republican Party in opposition to international free trade accords championed by Presidents Barack Obama and Bill Clinton.

That helped Trump shave off traditionally Democratic union voters. When Hillary Clinton lost the 2016 presidential election, she won just 51% of votes from union households, while Trump won by huge margins among white working class voters, according to exit polls at the time. Four years later, Biden took 56% of votes from union households, and union voters made up a slightly larger share of the electorate.

“The labor movement is changing, no question. We are having a younger and more diverse workforce,” said Lee Saunders, president of the American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees. “We are seeing a revitalization among young people and people of color who see that they’re being mistreated and they don’t have a true seat at the table.”

Martin Walsh, Biden’s first labor secretary who is now executive director of the pro hockey players’ union, said the early endorsements from organized labor were clear attempts to give union leaders more time to press Biden’s case to their members.

“Having so many unions coming out so early in the process tells you that the unions are solidifying their membership early and working their members early, so they don’t have a repeat of what happened in 2016,” Walsh said.

Among the youngest labor leaders is Roland Rexha, secretary-treasurer of the Marine Engineers’ Beneficial Association, which represents maritime workers including employees of the Staten Island Ferry. Rexha, who at 41 is the youngest member and the only Muslim on the AFL-CIO’s executive council, said it can be difficult to sell Biden to a group that was about three-quarters white men — a group with whom Trump has drawn majority support.

“Most labor unions do a good job of trying to explain to the members why they need to support the people that support them,” Rexha said. “It’s something that as leadership, we have had a hard time sometimes relaying to them.”

The broad union endorsements for Biden on Saturday mask some discontent for the president among organized labor. The United Auto Workers has withheld an endorsement over concerns about the electric vehicle transition the White House has championed. There was significant grumbling among labor groups that on the day Biden launched his campaign, he spoke to the building trades union — a group whose members are seen within the labor world as less reliably Democratic.

And then there is the fact that Biden’s much-touted infrastructure legislation will largely benefit construction workers — a group far more likely to be male and to vote Republican than the rest of the organized labor universe.

“There is some real progress, ironically, for construction workers, probably half of whom voted for Trump twice,” said Larry Cohen, a former president of the Communications Workers of America who has long been an adviser to Sen. Bernie Sanders, I-Vt.

“The messaging is as good as it’s ever been in 50 years or more, but there needs to be results.”

This article originally appeared in <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2023/06/17/us/politics/biden-again-has-union-support-but-the-unions-look-different-this-time.html">The New York Times</a>.