Controversial Elk Hunting Divides Oregon Coast Community

AI was utilized in the writing of this article.

Photo byByron JohnsononUnsplash

Jimmy Dean
March 28, 2024

In Surf Pines, a coastal area of Oregon, Ken Weist and his wife have cherished the sight of elk wandering through their backyard for the past seven years. This gated community, home to around 400 residents, finds solace in the presence of these majestic animals, considering them an integral part of its scenic beauty. However, recent changes have brought discomfort to the area, notably the noticeable reduction in elk groups, especially those accustomed to human presence. Sara Gage, residing just south of Surf Pines in Gearhart, fondly recalls witnessing "elk parades" along the dunes outside her window. The disappearance of these cherished animals has left a void in the community's identity.

The cause of this decline is not natural; it is the result of human intervention. Weist and others have expressed sadness upon hearing gunshots nearby, as hunters took the lives of 77 elk on a neighbor's land between 2021 and 2023, causing significant disruption and distress among residents.

While hunting elk in Surf Pines was legally permitted under the Oregon Department of Fish & Wildlife's (ODFW) landowner damage tag program, ethical concerns have been raised. Craig and Dana Weston, homeowners in Surf Pines, reported property damage to ODFW, resulting in the issuance of 80 tags for hunters to reduce the elk population. This raised concerns among neighbors like Jim Aalberg and Weist, who questioned the necessity and fairness of extensive hunting within their community.

Despite claims that the damage tag program aims to mitigate conflicts between elk and people, doubts persist. Weist, witnessing the aftermath of these hunts, questions the fairness and sporting spirit of hunting in a residential neighborhood, advocating for giving elk the opportunity to thrive in their natural habitats.

On the other hand, proponents of the program argue for its necessity, citing concerns about property damage and public security. Licensed hunters like Joe Surmeyer share their experiences to emphasize the careful organization of hunts and the importance of controlling elk numbers.

However, the broader impact of the program on coastal elk groups remains a matter of disagreement. With hundreds of tags issued in Clatsop County alone, questions arise about the effectiveness and necessity of the program. Despite ODFW's assertion that they are adhering to legislative intent, community members like Aalberg advocate for greater transparency and accountability in wildlife management practices.

As the debate continues, residents of Surf Pines and neighboring areas grapple with the implications of elk hunting on their beloved wildlife. The fate of these grand animals remains uncertain, prompting calls for a more nuanced and community-focused approach to wildlife management.

Get ahead of the game with WildAdvisorPro – the ultimate solution for simplifying hunting laws and regulations.