Are Dogs Hardwired to Feel Our Emotions? New Study Shares Key Insights

Photo byChris Arthur-CollinsonUnsplash

Dogs, with their expressive eyes and endearing behaviors, seem to have an innate ability to sense and respond to human emotions. This remarkable trait is believed to be the result of centuries of co-evolution and selective breeding alongside humans, according to a new study published in Animal Behaviour.

By comparing the responses of dogs and pet pigs to human sounds like crying and humming, researchers have shed light on how domestication may have fine-tuned dogs' emotional sensitivity.

The Science Behind Emotional Contagion

Humans and their animal companions share a unique bond, characterized by mutual attentiveness to each other’s emotional states.

Previous research has shown that horses and pigs can recognize and respond to human emotions, albeit differently. For instance, horses react more to human growls than laughter, while domestic pigs are more responsive to human sounds compared to their wild counterparts.

But the concept of emotional contagion, which is the ability to interpret and reflect the emotional states of another species, has been predominantly observed in dogs. Unlike many animals that primarily mirror the feelings of their own species, dogs have demonstrated a unique capacity to echo human emotions.

Dogs vs. Pigs: A Comparative Study

To investigate whether emotional contagion in animals is driven by universal vocal signals or is specific to companion animals like dogs, the new study compared the stress responses of dogs and pet pigs to human sounds.

Both dogs and pet pigs, raised in close proximity to humans, were subjected to recordings of crying and humming. The responses were observed and recorded, focusing on stress behaviors such as whining, yawning, and ear flicks.

The findings were telling. Dogs exhibited significant stress when they heard crying but remained largely indifferent to humming. On the other hand, while pigs did show some stress in response to crying, they were more stressed by the sound of humming.

This disparity suggests that dogs have a more refined ability to interpret and react to human emotional cues, likely due to their long history as companion animals.

Insights and Implications

Dr. Paula Pérez Fraga, a co-author of the study and an animal-behavior researcher, highlighted that dogs are exceptionally skilled at detecting the emotional content in human vocalizations.

In contrast, the pigs' stronger reaction to humming might indicate a lack of familiarity with such sounds, rather than an inability to experience emotional contagion.

Such a difference in responses between dogs and pigs could be attributed to the nature of their domestication. While dogs have been bred for companionship, pigs have traditionally been livestock. Therefore, the ability to mirror human emotions might be more developed in dogs due to their evolutionary background.

In summary, the close relationship between humans and dogs, shaped by centuries of selective breeding, has likely enhanced dogs' ability to read and mirror human emotions. This emotional connection not only underscores the special bond between dogs and their owners but also highlights the profound impact of domestication on animal behavior.