At least 12 die in motorcycle accidents before, during and after 2024 Sturgis rally

Motorcycle enthusiasts attend the 81st annual Sturgis Motorcycle Rally on Aug. 8, 2021, in Sturgis. (Scott Olson/Getty Images)

Three people died in motorcycle accidents during the recently concluded Sturgis Motorcycle Rally, according to the official tally of the state Department of Public Safety, but the actual number of motorcycle-involved traffic deaths in the state from the days before, during and after the event is 12.

The department, which includes the Highway Patrol, attributes traffic deaths to the rally only if they occur in a particular area of western South Dakota during the official rally dates, up to the morning of the last day. That number this year was three deaths, down from five last year.

When the scope is expanded to motorcycle-involved crashes in all of South Dakota during not only the rally dates but also the days just before and afterward, this year’s death toll is 12 and last year’s was 11 . Neither number includes any rallygoers who may have died in other states while traveling to or from the rally.

In other statistics, this year’s rally included more arrests for drug possession and impaired driving, but fewer crashes and citations.

Law enforcement also seized $71,504 in assets allegedly tied to criminal activity this year – more than 35 times the total from 2023 – and arrested seven men on sex trafficking charges.

Automated traffic counters showed a slight decrease in traffic compared to the previous five-year average.

The rally began Aug. 2 and ended Sunday.

Fatalities, injuries

Among the motorcycle-involved traffic deaths not included in the official tally, five occurred during the three days immediately preceding the rally’s Aug. 2 start, and two occurred the day after the rally’s Aug. 11 end.

Two others were omitted from the tally because one occurred during the rally but on Interstate 90 near Hartford, outside of the area of western South Dakota included in the official count; and the other occurred near Deadwood in western South Dakota on the final Sunday afternoon of the rally, after the Highway Patrol stopped counting rally statistics at 6 a.m. that day.

Ten of the people killed in this year’s crashes were driving Harley-Davidsons, and two were driving other kinds of motorcycles. Two of the deceased people were from South Dakota; others were from Iowa, Tennessee, Wisconsin, Minnesota and North Dakota; two were from Ohio; and the residence of three of the people has not yet been released.

Three of the 12 deceased people were wearing a helmet, seven were not wearing helmets, and helmet usage remains under investigation in the other two accidents.

In addition to fatal accidents, this year’s rally included 35 accidents that caused injuries and 54 that did not. Last year’s totals were 64 and 58, respectively.

Motorcycle-involved traffic deaths

Motorcycle-involved traffic deaths from the days before, during and after the 2024 Sturgis Motorcycle Rally, listed by name, age, place of residence, type of motorcycle driven, accident location, accident date and helmet status:

• 29-year-old male (name not yet released); 2007 Suzuki GSX-R1000; Interstate 90, mile marker 401, 2 miles east of Sioux Falls city limits; Monday, Aug. 12; helmet worn.
• 22-year-old male (name not yet released); 2014 BMW S1000 RR; U.S. Highway 14A, mile marker 21, 10 miles south of Spearfish; Monday, Aug. 12; helmet worn.
• 68-year-old male (name not yet released); 2001 Harley-Davidson FLHT; U.S. Highway 385, mile marker 120, 2 miles south of Deadwood; Sunday, Aug. 11; no helmet.
• David Leon Rowe ; 67-year-old male from Williamsburg, Iowa; 2017 Harley-Davidson Heritage; Interstate 90, mile marker 387, 1 mile west of Hartford; Friday, Aug. 9; helmet use under investigation.
• Ricky Dale Hardin ; 64-year-old male from Henry, Tennessee; 2007 Harley-Davidson STC; Interstate 90, mile marker 161, 2 miles west of Belvidere; Tuesday, Aug. 6; helmet use under investigation.
• Patti Jo Craig ; 69-year-old female from Watertown, Wisconsin; 2023 Harley-Davidson FLHXSE; U.S. Highway 85, mile marker 45, Spearfish; Monday, Aug. 5; no helmet.
• Jeffrey Allan Brookman ; 65-year-old male from Fostoria, Ohio; 2003 Harley-Davidson Electra Glide; Nemo Road and Pine Cone Avenue, 8 miles east of Nemo; Monday, Aug. 5; no helmet.
• Joel Gary Erickson ; 60-year-old male from Montgomery, Minnesota; 1994 Harley-Davidson Cruiser; 12445 Old Hill City Road, Hill City; Wednesday, July 31; no helmet.
• Austin Eugene Dahl ; 46-year-old male from Rapid City; 2010 Harley Davidson-FLTRX; Nemo Road and Estes Creek Road, 1 mile south of Nemo; Wednesday, July 31; helmet worn.
• Jerry A. Shafer ; 60-year-old male from Homeworth, Ohio; 2024 Harley-Davidson; U.S. Highway 18, mile marker 430 and 466th Ave.; 5 miles south of Lennox; Tuesday, July 30; no helmet.
• Kimberly Lynn Welch ; 53-year-old female from Rapid City; 2023 Harley-Davidson Street Glide; U.S. Highway 85, mile marker 3, 13 miles southwest of Cheyenne Crossing; Tuesday, July 30; no helmet.
• James Eugene Luchi; 73-year-old male from Watford City, North Dakota; 2017 Harley-Davidson Trike; U.S. 85 and SD Highway 168, 30 miles north of Belle Fourche; Tuesday, July 30; no helmet.

Source: South Dakota Department of Public Safety

Fewer vehicles counted

The state Department of Transportation logs the number of vehicles that enter Sturgis at any of nine traffic counters placed for the duration of the rally.

The final release from the DOT showed 470,987 vehicles hitting the counters Aug. 2-11. That was down 4% compared to the previous five-year average.

A video created with data from the European Space Agency’s Sentinel-2 satellite shows campgrounds around Sturgis before and during the Sturgis Motorcycle Rally. (Illustration by John Hult/South Dakota Searchlight)

Drugs and cash

Misdemeanor drug arrests were up 14% over 2023. Felony drug arrests were up 5%.

Law enforcement wrote 24 fewer citations of all kinds but 149 more warnings than in 2023.

In terms of raw numbers, the biggest change from 2023 came in the amount of seized cash. Officers collected $71,504 through asset forfeiture, a process by which law enforcement can seize money or property suspected of being used in crimes. In 2023, officers seized $2,005.

The 2024 pool of allegedly ill-gotten funds was collected on three different days. Two seizures took place in the Sturgis area; a third was seized near Rapid City.

The Department of Public Safety declined to offer details on the cases linked to the seized money, but civil cases filed in Meade County offer details on two of the situations behind the total.

The first case is tied to the Aug. 4 traffic stop of South Roy, Indiana, resident Robert Alan Ruple, court documents say. Ruple allegedly admitted to having a marijuana vape pen in his backpack. A search of his backpack allegedly yielded two vape cartridges, 6 grams of methamphetamine and a plastic bag with two-hundredths of a gram of fentanyl. The backpack also housed $11,094 in cash.

The other Meade County asset forfeiture case located by South Dakota Searchlight names Peter Christopher Colucci of Pleasantville, New York, as the alleged “owner, possessor or party of interest” for $29,710 in cash collected after a traffic stop conducted by an unnamed agency.

The complaint says a police dog reacted to the smell of drugs during the stop, prompting a search that turned up 2 grams of steroids and a packet with 13 grams of steroid tablets. Officers also allegedly found syringes, ledgers and cash, $2,120 in a brown paper bag and the remainder in a duct-taped safe.

As of Monday afternoon, no asset forfeiture case had yet been filed in Pennington County during the time period covered by the rally.

Sex trafficking sting

As in prior years, federal law enforcement and their local partners were involved in a sex trafficking sting during the rally. Agents with the Internet Crimes Against Children task force posed as underage children in electronic communications with people seeking to pay for sex.

According to the U.S. Attorney’s Office, the following seven men were arrested and charged with crimes as listed in the 2024 sting operation:

• Brockton Dominquez, 26, Rapid City – Enticement of a Minor Using the Internet.
• Eli Poorman, 20, Rapid City – Attempted Commercial Sex Trafficking of a Minor.
• Dustin Day, 20, Piedmont – Attempted Commercial Sex Trafficking of a Minor.
• Vance Coats, 25, Box Elder – Attempted Enticement of a Minor Using the Internet.
• Brandon Bishop, 36, Rapid City – Attempted Enticement of a Minor Using the Internet.
• Corey Simon, 36, Rapid City – Attempted Enticement of a Minor Using the Internet.
• Aaron Ray Williams, Jr., 23, Rapid City – Attempted Enticement of a Minor Using the Internet.

SUBSCRIBE: GET THE MORNING HEADLINES DELIVERED TO YOUR INBOX

DONATE: SUPPORT NEWS YOU TRUST