Cardinals urged to trade away 2024 All-Star to kickstart rebuild

The St. Louis Cardinals did not meet expectations in 2024. They could be headed for a rebuild meaning some star players could be traded for younger talent.

When listing players the Cardinals could trade to kickstart their rebuild. FanSided's Zach Pressnell urged the team to trade All-Star closer Ryan Helsley.

"Last season, the hottest market at the trade deadline was the relief pitcher market. Pitchers like Tanner Scott and Carlos Estevez garnered huge returns when they were dealt at the deadline," wrote Pressnell. "Neither of those two pitchers are nearly as dominant as the Cardinals' closer, Ryan Helsley, who St. Louis would be wise to move if they're ready to begin their rebuild."

Helsley was named in All-Star for the second time in his career. He led Major League Baseball in saves with 49. However, if the Cardinals do not expect to be competitive, they could get a haul for Helsley.

"Having an elite closer is worthwhile for the competitive teams in the league. But as you move down the line, bullpen arms are no longer that valuable because they cannot generate a WAR like starting pitchers or position players," wrote Pressnell. "Imagine how much less valuable Emmanuel Clase would have been on the Chicago White Sox this season."

Helsely is in his final year of arbitration and will be a free agent in 2026. Spotrac projects him to sign a six-year, $81 million deal in free agency.

"For St. Louis, dealing Helsley would hurt, but it would be the smartest decision to make," wrote Pressnell. "Helsley recorded 49 saves in 66.1 innings in 2024. He held a 2.04 ERA and a 1.10 WHIP. His triple digit fastball often dominates even the best hitters across the league."

More MLB: Mets could sign $152 million shortstop and shuffle infield if Pete Alonso leaves