Barred From Criminal Cases, Judge Continues to Collect $109,973 Salary

Photo byChestnuthill Twp.Gov

Chestnuthill Township, PA- Being a judge is no small task, as it demands immense responsibility and an unwavering commitment to upholding the law. However, Magisterial District Judge Colleen Mancuso appears to be under considerable public scrutiny. Despite her temporary reassignment from specific judicial duties imposed by the President Judge of Monroe County Court of Common Pleas, she continues to collect a hefty annual salary of $109,973, effectively for less work.

Administrative order issued on Dec. 28, 2023, Monroe County Court of Common Pleas President Judge Margherita Patti-WorthingtonPhoto byCourt of Common Pleas

This move has come with its sets of queries and concerns. As the spouse of the newly elected Monroe County District Attorney Michael Mancuso, the adjustment in her duties raises eyebrows. Despite the questionable circumstances, Mrs. Mancuso's husband has stated, "My assistant district attorneys continue to regularly appear before Judge Mancuso. Virtually all defendants and their attorneys are opting to have her continue to preside over these cases." This is a scenario that unfortunately leads one to ponder on potential intimidation, given that the DA is their ultimate superior.

Furthermore, it is hard to overlook the considerable financial implications of her reassignment. With some of her cases being re-routed to another judge, an extra expense of approximately $300 per day could be incurred, a cost which inevitably falls on the shoulders of the taxpayers. The question begs, is this truly a judicious use of public funds?

Photo bySource Administrative Office Of PA Courts, Proposed Budget of the Unified Judicial System 2023-24

This is not an isolated incident either. Prior instances of reassignment spotlight a recurring issue. The pattern indicates an underlying problem that warrants public attention.

The ultimate purpose of the justice system is to safeguard the integrity and impartiality of legal proceedings. Judge Mancuso's capacity to deliver unbiased justice amidst these recurring issues and concerns is now a pressing matter of public concern.

The public deserves a legal system beyond reproach and void of potential conflicts of interest. Mrs. Mancuso has firmly stated that she "has no plans" to resign, prompting speculation about whether her priorities lie with the public's interest or her own. Her resignation could be a step towards restoring faith in the system and ensuring the judicious use of taxpayer money.

If you have any inquiries in regards to Judicial Ethics, contact the:

Judicial Ethics Advisory Board

Pennsylvania Judicial Center

601 Commonwealth Ave.

Suite 6100

P. O. Box 62333

Harrisburg, PA 17106-2333

p: 717-705-1785

f: 717-231-9594

Email