All the Theories on What Tell Me Lies’ Lucy Did to Lydia to Make Her ‘Never Forgive’ Her

This article contains mentions of sexual assault.

Tell Me Lies Is Not a Love Story, But It's Not Trying to Be

Tell Me Lies is perhaps the most realistic depiction of relationships, romantic or otherwise, that happen to us when we’re going through college. In season 1, Lucy and Lydia were fast friends. But now, they don’t talk to each other and their friendship seems irreconcilable. What on earth did Lucy do to Lydia that was so unforgivable?

Related: Grace Van Patten & Jackson White’s Off-Screen Relationship Is Drastically Different From Their Tell Me Lies Characters

How to Watch Mastermind: To Think Like a Killer to See the True Crime Series From Dakota & Elle Fanning

Appearing in the show’s first season in episodes 1 and 5, Lydia has a larger part to play in season 2. “We definitely learn more about her, and we learn more about the things that happen in Lucy and Lydia’s friendship that even make it possible for Lydia to end up with Stephen because, obviously, something has to happen in a friendship for you to end up with your best friend’s ex,” Meaghan Oppenheimer told Screenrant . For now, it’s a big mystery but there are fan theories for…

Mindhunter Was Great, but It Did Its Real-Life Star a Huge Disservice

What did Lucy do to Lydia?