Get updates delivered to you daily. Free and customizable.
The Conversation U.S.
Wild ginseng is declining, but small-scale ‘diggers’ aren’t the main threat to this native plant − and they can help save it
By Justine Law, Sonoma State University,
16 hours ago
Across Appalachia, September marks the start of ginseng season, when thousands of people roam the hills searching for hard-to-reach patches of this highly prized plant.
Many people know ginseng as an ingredient in vitamin supplements or herbal tea. That ginseng is grown commercially on farms in Wisconsin and Ontario, Canada. In contrast, wild American ginseng is an understory plant that can live for decades in the forests of the Appalachian Mountains. The plant’s taproot grows throughout its life and sells for hundreds of dollars per pound, primarily to East Asian customers who consume it for health reasons.
Because it’s such a valuable medicinal plant, harvesting ginseng has helped families in mountainous regions of states such as Kentucky, West Virginia, Tennessee, North Carolina and Ohio weather economic ups and downs since the late 1700s.
Most harvesting takes place in Appalachia’s long-enduring forest commons – forests across the region that historically were managed and used by local residents. Many people in Appalachia still believe that, at least in practice, forests should be common property , even as large swaths of the region’s forests have been placed under state or federal ownership over the past century.
Recently, however, it has become harder for diggers to harvest ginseng from public lands, such as national forests. Those who flout regulations are receiving steeper fines and, sometimes, prison sentences.
I’m an environmental geographer who studies rural livelihoods and conservation in North American forests. As I see it, large-scale threats to ginseng, including mining and climate change, are bigger concerns than small-scale harvesting by negligent diggers. I believe many diggers can be valuable conservation partners.
– A requirement that diggers plant the berries from ginseng they’ve dug at the harvest site
Over the past decade, state and federal agencies have tightened ginseng regulations and ramped up enforcement. These actions were spurred largely by rising ginseng prices and by evidence that ginseng was sometimes sold on black markets in exchange for illegal drugs .
States with sizable ginseng harvests often conduct undercover and sting operations to detect illegal harvesting. Some national parks and preserves even dye or attach microchips to ginseng plants to make illegal collection easier to spot.
Meanwhile, the U.S. Forest Service has indefinitely suspended ginseng harvesting in national forests in Kentucky , North Carolina , Georgia and Tennessee . These closures cover over 5,000 square miles (13,000 square kilometers) of Appalachian forestland – an area larger than the state of Connecticut.
According to wildlife officers I’ve spoken with, however, many arrests are of diggers who don’t follow regulations precisely and who might, for instance, harvest sustainably but on closed land. Typically, these diggers still see the forest as a commons that everyone should be able to access and don’t think contemporary ginseng regulations are fair or useful.
Some scholars call this phenomenon “ folk crime ,” a catchall phrase for widely tolerated offenses such as jaywalking in cities or harvesting wildlife in rural areas.
My archival and ethnographic research shows that ordinary diggers have been blamed for the scarcity of ginseng since at least the late 1800s. In a 1903 book, for example, horticulturalist M.G. Kains argued that “the principal agents in the extermination of the native supply are the ginseng diggers … they exercise no judgment.”
But diggers are not, and never have been, the only reason for small ginseng populations. Starting in the late 1800s, forests across virtually all of the eastern United States were logged for farming, fuel and industry.
I have interviewed dozens of ginseng diggers. Nearly all of them harvest only a portion of the plants in a patch, and they will wait until a plant’s berries are ripe before they dig it up and replant the berries.
Some diggers tend secret, secluded ginseng patches for many years. Others have purchased and planted seeds to establish new populations. A 2016 study found that digger-planted seeds germinate at much higher rates than seeds that fall naturally on the forest floor.
A different way forward could involve diggers in ginseng restoration on a broad scale. There’s already a robust movement to plant ginseng seeds under existing forest canopy on private land , but most diggers don’t own land. A complementary effort might distribute seeds to them for planting in designated zones. Participating could be a way to earn ginseng harvesting permits in state or national forests.
Threats to ginseng across Appalachia are a legitimate concern, and curbing profligate overharvesting is important. But diggers helped facilitate the existence and persistence of ginseng populations, and they could be knowledgeable, skillful conservation allies. In my view, casting them as villains and barring them from nearly all public land is both unjust and ineffective.
This article is republished from The Conversation , a nonprofit, independent news organization bringing you facts and trustworthy analysis to help you make sense of our complex world. It was written by: Justine Law , Sonoma State University
Justine Law does not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organization that would benefit from this article, and has disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.
deer are causing the greatest decline in ginseng in my 478ac of land. I have been planting seed for many years o ly to wat h the deer eat them. up one summer and then they never come back up when eaten several years in a row. but the trespassers that trespass on my posted property have made me the most angry. I had planted a large patch and built an 8ft fence around it to keep the deer from eating them only to have a criminal dig them all up in one day. so don't tell me they help. Many don't care that they dig 2 prong plants and they clean a patch out as complete as they can. They are thieves that don't plant the seeds but steal them if anything. Perhaps you are nieve as to the thief that is going on in the woods.
Get updates delivered to you daily. Free and customizable.
It’s essential to note our commitment to transparency:
Our Terms of Use acknowledge that our services may not always be error-free, and our Community Standards emphasize our discretion in enforcing policies. As a platform hosting over 100,000 pieces of content published daily, we cannot pre-vet content, but we strive to foster a dynamic environment for free expression and robust discourse through safety guardrails of human and AI moderation.