California's Economy: How Retail Crime is Driving Customers to Amazon

Photo byAuthor Edit

The safety and security of our customers and employees is our top priority,' says CVS CEO Karen Lynch, but as urban crime continues to plague California's cities, that priority is becoming increasingly difficult to maintain. The surge in shoplifting and organized retail crime is not only forcing pharmacies and retailers to lock up goods and hire more security, but also driving customers online, where they can shop with ease and safety.

As Amazon CEO Andy Jassy noted, this shift is 'driving a lot of customers' to online shopping platforms, and it's having a profound impact on California's economy, threatening to upend the state's retail landscape and deprive local communities of vital jobs and tax revenue.

This article will explore the ways in which California's urban crime wave is reshaping the state's economy, and what it means for the future of retail in the Golden State.

Jassy says the high rate of crime in U.S. cities is driving customers to shop online, citing the unpleasant experience of visiting urban pharmacies. He told investors Thursday that the rise in shoplifting and security measures like locked cabinets in physical stores has made shopping online more appealing.

Amazon's pharmacy services, launched in 2020, have seen significant growth as the company expands its offerings. Pharmacy chains like CVS have been forced to increase security or close stores due to crime. CVS CEO Karen Lynch says the lack of prosecution for shoplifters is a major issue, with even minor products being locked up to prevent theft.

California has the largest economy out of all U.S. states, so you could imagine that the Golden State plays a large role in this shoplifting epidemic. When you look into recent reports on shoplifting crime in California, they reveal a complex and evolving situation, characterized by rising incidents and legislative responses aimed at addressing the issue.

Rising Shoplifting Rates

Recent crime statistics for 2023 indicate a continued increase in shoplifting across California. Reported incidents of shoplifting are 28% higher than in 2019, despite a 9% decrease in commercial burglaries in 2023. This increase is primarily concentrated in four counties: Alameda, Los Angeles, Sacramento, and San Mateo. The rise in shoplifting began in mid-2021 and has persisted through 2023, with significant increases noted in urban areas like Los Angeles and the Bay Area.

Legislative Responses

California has seen several legislative efforts to curb retail theft, Proposition 47 (2014): This measure reclassified many drug and property offenses, including shoplifting under $950, from felonies to misdemeanors. Critics argue that this has contributed to the increase in shoplifting.

Assembly Bill 33: This bill extends the operation of regional property crimes task forces until January 1, 2026, focusing on combating organized retail theft, which is a significant component of the overall retail theft problem.

Proposed Assembly Bill 1772: This bill calls for required jail time for repeat shoplifters, with penalties ranging from one to three years depending on the circumstances. It aims to add consequences for repeat offenders while maintaining the $950 threshold for misdemeanors.

Ballot Measure for Felony Shoplifting: A proposed measure seeks to make shoplifting a felony for repeat offenders. This initiative has sparked debates about its potential impact on low-income individuals and its political implications, especially in the context of upcoming congressional races.

Organized Retail Theft

Organized retail theft remains a significant concern, with the California Highway Patrol (CHP) coordinating efforts to combat it through regional task forces. These efforts are crucial as organized retail theft involves not just shoplifting but also other crimes like commercial burglary and identity theft, contributing to an estimated $30 billion in economic losses annually.

Data and Reporting Challenges

There are notable limitations in the available crime data. Retail theft incidents, especially low-value thefts, are likely underreported, and there are inconsistencies in how different law enforcement agencies report and categorize offenses. Additionally, some agencies did not report crime numbers for part or all of 2023, which may affect the accuracy of statewide numbers.

My Conclusion

The rise in shoplifting in California is a multifaceted issue influenced by legislative changes, economic factors, and organized criminal activities. While we can notice that there are some efforts underway to address the problem through stricter laws and coordinated enforcement, the effectiveness of these measures remains a topic of ongoing debate and analysis.

References:

Public Policy Institute of California. (2023). Commercial burglaries fell in 2023, but shoplifting continued to rise.

Public Policy Institute of California. (n.d.). Testimony: Crime data on retail theft and robberies in California.

California Highway Patrol. (n.d.). Organized Retail Theft Program.

CBS News. (2024). California initiative aims to crack down on shoplifting, make it felony for repeat offenders.

ABC7 News. (2024). Shoplifting, retail crime on the rise in California, Proposition 47 to blame?

Fox Business. (2024). Shoplifting, retail crime driving customers to Amazon, CEO says.

Fox Business. (2024). CVS engaging with AGs to combat retail theft, working to dismantle 'these criminal operations'.