Opinion - From Quill to Clickbait - Why Michigan Newspapers Have Always Played Political Favorites

Photo byThumbwind Publications

Newspapers in Michigan, like in many other states, have a long history of political bias, with some of the most prominent publications leaning toward specific ideologies. This trend has persisted for over a century, evolving in line with political shifts both statewide and nationally. Understanding the political bias of newspapers in Michigan involves exploring key publications from both the past and present.

Historical Political Bias

A hundred years ago, Michigan’s newspapers were heavily influenced by the political environment of the time, with clear leanings toward specific parties. The Detroit News, founded in 1873, has long been a conservative outlet, consistently aligning itself with Republican viewpoints. This right-of-center stance is reflected in the paper's history of endorsing Republican candidates and its opposition to liberal policies. For instance, during the mid-20th century, the Detroit News became a key supporter of conservative policies during the Cold War, advocating for smaller government and more business-friendly regulations​(Media Bias/Fact Check)​(Wikipedia).

On the opposite end of the spectrum, The Michigan Daily, the student newspaper at the University of Michigan, which began publishing in 1890, has historically leaned toward more progressive views, aligning itself with Democratic policies over time. While this publication was less influential in shaping state-level politics, its reach among younger audiences fostered a progressive ideological slant in its reporting and editorial decisions, which continues today​(Media Bias/Fact Check).

Modern Political Bias

Today, the political leanings of Michigan newspapers remain as varied as ever. The Detroit News continues its legacy as a conservative-leaning publication, consistently presenting a right-of-center viewpoint. Notably, in the 2016 election, The Detroit News broke with tradition by endorsing Libertarian candidate Gary Johnson rather than the Republican nominee Donald Trump, underscoring its conservative but nuanced editorial stance​(Media Bias/Fact Check).

The paper remains a reliable source of factual reporting but retains its conservative editorial slant on issues such as taxation, government regulation, and social policy.

In contrast, MLive, which is part of a larger network of publications across Michigan, offers a more balanced and centrist approach. MLive’s collection of newspapers, which includes titles like The Ann Arbor News and The Grand Rapids Press, publishes a wide range of perspectives, although certain local outlets within the MLive network may tilt slightly to the left or right depending on the region they serve. For instance, coverage in more liberal-leaning areas such as Ann Arbor tends to reflect progressive views, while outlets in more conservative areas like Grand Rapids offer a more right-leaning editorial line​(Media Bias/Fact Check)​

The Influence of Digital Media

In recent years, new digital publications with clear political ties have emerged in Michigan, reflecting national trends of partisan media expansion. One prominent example is The Michigan Star, a conservative-leaning digital outlet that has gained attention for its coverage of Republican fundraising efforts and conservative policy initiatives. The site, part of a larger network run by conservative activists, has been criticized for presenting a highly selective version of events that supports Republican narratives, particularly during the Trump administration​.

Additionally, new online platforms like The Center Square, a conservative news site that launched in Michigan in 2017, have further bolstered right-leaning news coverage in the state. Supported by GOP-aligned donors, The Center Square focuses on statehouse reporting, often framing issues in ways that align with conservative values such as limited government and free-market principles​(Governing).

The Importance of Recognizing Bias

Understanding the political bias of newspapers in Michigan is crucial for readers seeking objective news. While newspapers like MLive and The Michigan Daily aim for balance, outlets such as The Detroit News and The Michigan Star present more ideologically driven perspectives. This pattern reflects broader trends in American journalism, where the media landscape is increasingly fragmented along political lines, with local newspapers playing a pivotal role in shaping political discourse within their communities.