Homebuyers Opt for Risky Neighborhoods to Afford Rising Costs

Photo byGetty Images

Trade-offs Emerge as Affordability Trumps Safety in Housing Market

As housing prices soar, a surprising trend is emerging: more homebuyers are willing to prioritize affordability over safety. According to a recent Redfin report, 17.3% of potential buyers are ready to consider properties in higher-risk areas if it means staying within their budget.

Generational Divide in Risk Tolerance

The survey, conducted in February by Qualtrics and including responses from nearly 3,000 homeowners and renters, sheds light on how different age groups are navigating the housing crunch. Gen Z stands out with 23.7% willing to compromise on safety for affordability, compared to 18.1% of millennials and 17.5% of Gen Xers. Baby boomers, however, are less inclined, with only 5.5% willing to make such sacrifices.

“Younger generations are facing a severe housing supply crunch and historically high prices,” said Redfin Senior Economist Elijah de la Campa. “Their lower earnings relative to older generations mean they are often forced to make tougher decisions to secure a home they can afford.”

Safety Remains a Key Concern

Despite the willingness to compromise, safety is still a significant factor for many. The survey found that 16.4% of respondents cited safety and crime as primary reasons for relocating. Among these, Gen Xers are the most safety-conscious, with 20.8% concerned, followed by baby boomers (17.6%), millennials (15.3%), and Gen Z (12.8%).

Navigating High-Risk Areas

The Redfin survey also explored attitudes toward living in areas prone to natural or climate-related disasters. A notable 28% of participants expressed willingness to reside in such environments if they are affordable.

Recent data underscores shifting migration patterns. In high-fire-risk regions, 97,535 people moved in while 34,170 moved out. Texas, with its growing fire risk, saw a net inflow of 30,156 people, a significant increase from 28.7% in 2022. Conversely, California's fire-prone areas experienced a net outflow of 6,937 in 2023, compared to a slight net inflow the previous year.

In high-flood-risk counties, 16,144 more people moved in than out, with Florida leading the influx. However, Miami-Dade County faced a net outflow of 47,597 people in 2023.

Insurance Crisis and Housing Market Dynamics

The ongoing insurance crisis is exacerbating these trends, with skyrocketing premiums and some homeowners losing coverage entirely. For instance, Allstate plans to increase insurance costs by 34%, impacting over 350,000 residents, while State Farm sought a 30% hike last month and ceased writing new policies in 2022.

“Rising insurance costs and worsening natural disasters are driving people out of risky areas, yet many are replaced by others less concerned about climate risks,” de la Campa noted. “For many, factors like cost of living and proximity to family take precedence over disaster risk, though these priorities are shifting in high-impact areas like California and Florida.”