CFA Urges Buyers to Cap Agent Fees at 2% Amidst Real Estate Industry Shake-Up

Photo bygetty images

As the real estate industry braces for a significant shift with new regulations set to take effect on August 17, the Consumer Federation of America (CFA) is offering crucial advice for homebuyers navigating these changes. The CFA’s latest guidance emphasizes negotiating agent compensation at 2 percent or less of a home’s sale price, aiming to empower consumers and challenge long-standing industry practices.

The impending rule changes, part of a broader National Association of Realtors (NAR) settlement, introduce new standards that impact both buyers and sellers. These include eliminating mandatory compensation offers to buyer brokers on Multiple Listing Services (MLS) and requiring written contracts between buyers and agents before home tours. In light of these changes, the CFA’s recommendations seek to demystify the evolving landscape and ensure consumers are not disadvantaged.

Key CFA Recommendations for Buyers

1. Negotiate in Dollars, Not Percentages: The CFA advises buyers to settle on agent compensation in dollar terms, aiming for no more than 2 percent of the home’s sale price. This approach is designed to mitigate the industry’s traditional commission rates, which have often hovered around 5-6 percent. Stephen Brobeck, CFA Senior Fellow, argues that this dollar-based negotiation can help buyers avoid inflated costs and incentivize more competitive practices.
2. Understand and Vet Your Agent: Buyers should thoroughly vet their agents, considering whether they are brokers or associate brokers, their recent sales performance, and client reviews. Furthermore, agents should provide clear contract terms upfront, allowing buyers ample time to review and understand the agreements before committing.
3. Avoid Premature Financial Commitments: The CFA warns against signing contracts that require compensation before a buyer has fully decided to engage an agent. Contracts should be straightforward, and buyers should feel free to seek legal advice if needed.

Navigating New Rules and Market Changes

The upcoming settlement marks a departure from industry norms where sellers often covered buyer broker compensation, a practice now restricted from MLS listings. Buyers are encouraged to negotiate compensation directly with their agents and potentially include these terms in purchase offers. This shift reflects a broader movement towards more transparent and negotiable real estate transactions.

CFA's Perspective on Industry Practices

Brobeck highlights the need for change in an industry historically resistant to reform. The CFA's recommendations come in response to both the U.S. Department of Justice’s antitrust actions and ongoing consumer dissatisfaction with high commission rates. By advocating for a 2 percent cap and greater transparency, the CFA aims to level the playing field and offer consumers more control over their real estate transactions.

As the real estate industry adapts to these new regulations, consumers are advised to stay informed, negotiate wisely, and seek competent, transparent agents to guide them through this transformative period.