Real Estate Commissions Revolution: How New Rules Could Save You Thousands

Photo byGetty Images

The real estate industry is standing at a crossroads, facing changes that could reshape how Americans buy and sell homes. For decades, real estate commissions have survived technological disruption, industry shifts, and regulatory scrutiny. Now, a recent federal lawsuit has sparked a seismic shift that could finally bring these commissions down, altering the landscape for homebuyers, sellers, and agents alike.

A Verdict That Shakes the Industry

In October 2023, a federal jury in Missouri delivered a landmark ruling that found the National Association of Realtors (NAR) and several major brokerages guilty of conspiring to inflate real estate commissions. The fallout was swift and significant: NAR and the brokerages settled the case for hundreds of millions of dollars, agreeing to change longstanding practices that have long shaped the industry. As of August 2024, the way consumers pay real estate agents has begun to shift, potentially leading to a "price war" among buyer agents and a more competitive market overall.

How Real Estate Commissions Are Evolving

The changes introduced by the lawsuit are poised to transform the dynamics of real estate transactions. Under the new system, home sellers are no longer automatically responsible for covering the fees of both their own agent and the buyer’s agent. Instead, buyers will need to negotiate and pay their own agents separately, marking a significant departure from the traditional structure.

This shift is expected to ignite fierce competition among buyer agents, who will now have to actively market their services and negotiate their fees with prospective clients. Historically, real estate commissions have hovered around 5%, often with little variation. However, industry experts, like Stephen Brobeck of the Consumer Federation of America, predict that commissions could drop below 4%—or even 3%—as agents compete more openly on price.

A New Reality for Buyers and Sellers

The impact of these changes will be felt most acutely by homebuyers, who may need to budget for their agent’s fees as an additional, out-of-pocket expense. With an average commission of 2.5% on a $400,000 home sale amounting to $10,000, this new responsibility could alter the financial calculations for many prospective homeowners.

However, there is hope that federal regulators may step in to allow these commissions to be included in mortgage financing, easing the burden on buyers. The Federal Housing Finance Agency is expected to address this issue in the near future, which could offer some relief to buyers navigating this new landscape.

The Industry Faces Internal and External Pressure

The NAR’s legal woes are just one part of the broader turbulence shaking the real estate industry. The organization has also been rocked by a sexual harassment scandal that led to the resignation of its president in 2023, followed by the departure of its next president and longtime CEO. These controversies have created unrest within the NAR, with some brokerages, like Redfin, severing ties with the organization and others questioning its relevance.

Adding to the challenges, two influential real estate agents have launched a rival trade group, the American Real Estate Association (AREA). While AREA is not positioning itself as a direct replacement for NAR, its emergence signals growing dissatisfaction and the potential for further fragmentation within the industry.

The Consumer Advantage

For consumers, these changes could finally bring about the competitive, transparent marketplace that many have long desired. Buyers and sellers may soon have more power to negotiate commissions and shop around for the best deals, much like they do when choosing a mortgage lender.

But as with any major shift, there are risks. The complexity of real estate transactions means that consumers, who typically buy or sell a home only once every several years, may still find themselves at a disadvantage in negotiations. Educating consumers about their options and encouraging them to compare rates and services will be crucial in ensuring they benefit from the evolving market.

Conclusion: Navigating the New Real Estate Landscape

As the dust settles from the NAR lawsuit and related industry upheavals, one thing is clear: the real estate market is entering a new era. For agents, this means adapting to increased competition and potentially lower fees. For consumers, it presents an opportunity to save money and take greater control over their transactions.

The future of real estate commissions is uncertain, but one thing is certain: change is on the horizon, and those who navigate it wisely will thrive.