Real Estate Commission Overhaul: How New Rules Will Reshape Your Homebuying and Selling Experience

Photo byGetty Images

On August 17, 2024, a landmark shift in real estate commissions took effect, ushering in a new era of transparency and potential disruption for homebuyers and sellers. Following a protracted legal battle, the National Association of Realtors (NAR) and major brokerages agreed to transformative changes that could reshape the way real estate transactions unfold. Here’s a deep dive into what these changes mean and how they could impact your next move in the housing market.

The Traditional Commission Landscape

Historically, real estate commissions have been a significant factor in home transactions. Typically, sellers paid a commission of about 5% of the home's sale price, split evenly between the listing agent and the buyer’s agent. For a $400,000 home, this meant $20,000 in fees, with $10,000 allocated to each agent. This system was designed to incentivize both agents to facilitate a smooth transaction.

However, the actual dynamics of payment were less transparent. Though the seller covered the commission, the cost was effectively rolled into the home’s sale price, indirectly impacting the buyer.

New Rules, New Realities

The new regulations represent a seismic shift in real estate practices. Under the new system, listing agents can no longer offer compensation to buyer’s agents through NAR-affiliated Multiple Listing Services (MLS). Instead, buyer’s agents must now establish a written agreement with their clients specifying their fee before showing properties. This change aims to enhance transparency, ensuring buyers are fully aware of their agent’s costs upfront.

David Druey, Florida regional president at Centennial Bank, notes the potential for clarity: “It’s always good when people understand what they are and are not paying for.” Yet, this newfound transparency comes with its own set of challenges. While sellers and listing agents can still negotiate compensation off the MLS, the formal public display of these offers has been eliminated.

A Double-Edged Sword

The new rules have sparked diverse predictions about their impact. On one side, industry experts like Vishal Garg, CEO of Better, anticipate a competitive "buy-side price war," where buyer agents compete fiercely for clients, potentially driving down costs. On the flip side, concerns are mounting that the added complexity might deter some buyers from using agents altogether. Ken H. Johnson, a real estate economist at Florida Atlantic University, warns that this could lead to a more convoluted process, extending the house-hunting period and complicating negotiations.

First-Time Buyers: A Critical Concern

The most pressing issue may be for first-time homebuyers, who already face significant financial pressures. Traditionally, commissions were included in the home’s sale price, but with the new system, buyers might be required to cover these fees directly. Dave Liniger, chairman and co-founder of RE/MAX, voices a common concern: “Most of those buyers are scraping the barrel to the bottom to come up with a down payment.” Without the ability to roll commission costs into their mortgages, first-time buyers may find themselves squeezed even tighter.

Anticipations are that the Federal Housing Finance Agency (FHFA) may eventually revise mortgage rules to accommodate these changes, providing some relief for buyers. “There’s going to be pressure on them to allow that,” Liniger adds. Meanwhile, NAR is already engaging with mortgage giants Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae to explore potential solutions.

Conclusion: Navigating the New Terrain

The overhaul in real estate commission structures is a bold step toward greater transparency, yet it introduces complexities that could alter the dynamics of buying and selling homes. As the industry adjusts, consumers and agents alike will need to navigate these changes carefully, keeping an eye on emerging trends and potential adjustments in mortgage policies.