From Small Town to Silver Screen: Mike Faist’s Journey from Gahanna, Ohio to Hollywood Stardom

Photo byGetty Images

In a twist of fate that echoes the plot of a classic underdog story, the quiet town of Gahanna, Ohio—recently crowned America’s hottest ZIP code—has produced an unexpected star: Mike Faist. Known for his breakout roles in “West Side Story” and “Challengers,” Faist’s rise to fame mirrors the unassuming charm of his hometown, which has now earned a spotlight of its own.

The Heart of Gahanna: A Star is Born

Gahanna, a suburb nestled on the outskirts of Columbus, might seem an unlikely birthplace for Hollywood talent. Yet, for Mike Faist, it was the perfect incubator for his dreams. Born in January 1992, Faist grew up surrounded by the deep roots of his family's real estate empire, which spans across Ohio and Florida. His parents, Julia and Kurt Faist, adopted him as a baby and nurtured his passion for performance from a young age.

The Faists’ influence on the local real estate market is substantial, with records showing ownership of at least 15 properties in the Columbus metro area and seven more in Sarasota, Florida. Among these is a modest three-bedroom home in Gahanna, purchased for $100,000 in 1994, which may well be the place where Faist’s love for the arts first took root.

From Dance Lessons to Broadway Dreams

Faist’s journey from a small-town boy to a Tony-nominated actor began with an early fascination with classic Hollywood. Films starring Gene Kelly and Fred Astaire, discovered on old VHS tapes lying around the house, sparked a passion in Faist that would shape his future. “Gene Kelly was definitely the guy I wanted to emulate,” he once shared, describing how he begged his parents to enroll him in dance classes.

His early exposure to musicals like “Singin’ in the Rain” and “An American in Paris” led him to community theater, where he began to hone his craft. While other kids his age were spending their summers at the pool, Faist was performing on stage and working construction jobs to help with his family’s real estate business—a grounding experience that instilled in him a strong work ethic and a love for the arts.

The Leap to New York and Beyond

At 17, Faist took a bold step away from his Midwestern roots and moved to New York City to chase his Broadway dreams. With the support of his father, who drove him to Manhattan, Faist faced the daunting city alone. “I was terrified,” he admitted, recalling the moment his father left him at a dorm-style house in Midtown. But the fear was outweighed by his determination to succeed.

Faist’s perseverance paid off when he landed a role in the off-Broadway production of “Newsies” in 2012. His big break came with “Dear Evan Hansen,” where he originated the role of Connor Murphy, earning a Tony nomination. This role caught the eye of Steven Spielberg, who cast him in the 2021 film adaptation of “West Side Story,” propelling Faist into the Hollywood spotlight.

A Return Home

Despite his growing fame, Faist has remained deeply connected to his roots. In 2021, he returned to Gahanna to care for his father during a battle with pulmonary fibrosis, a fight that Kurt Faist ultimately lost in 2023. This period of his life underscored Faist’s commitment to family and his hometown, which he continues to champion.

Gahanna’s Rising Star

Faist’s success has brought new attention to Gahanna, a town often overshadowed by its larger neighbors. But as Faist notes, the area is undergoing a transformation. “When I was growing up in Columbus, you didn’t go downtown... Now I go back and it’s like the new Brooklyn, almost. Very hipster. There’s a lot of trendy places; there’s a lot of art community interest,” he remarked, reflecting on the city’s revitalization.

With major tech companies like Intel and Google planning expansions in the area, Gahanna’s future looks brighter than ever—much like the career of its hometown hero, Mike Faist.