Navigating the New Normal: Inside the MLS Fine Controversy and the Path Forward

Photo byReal Estate News/Shutterstock

Realtors Face $500 Fines Amid MLS Rule Changes: The Cost of Compliance in a Post-NAR Settlement World

As the real estate industry grapples with seismic shifts following the National Association of Realtors' (NAR) settlement, one cost has emerged as a symbol of both compliance and frustration: a $500 fine for a seemingly innocuous infraction. The fine was imposed on a Realtor who mentioned "co-op commission" in agent-only remarks for a listing—an act now considered a violation in the wake of sweeping rule changes that took effect before the August 17 deadline.

Stellar MLS, the third-largest multiple listing service (MLS) in the U.S., has been at the forefront of these changes, implementing new rules well ahead of the mandated date. "We did it intentionally to give people time to adapt before the deadline," explains Merri Jo Cowen, CEO of Stellar MLS. Her team launched an extensive educational campaign, including 104 communications, broker and agent forums, Facebook Live sessions, and other resources aimed at preparing its 83,000 subscribers for the new regulations.

The challenge, however, lies in balancing enforcement with support. "We have to protect not only Stellar but also our brokers and agents," Cowen says. She emphasizes that the $500 fine is not about generating revenue but about ensuring compliance and deterring violations in an environment where scrutiny is heightened. "We’re not the bad guys here," Cowen asserts. "We are the enforcers, and we take this responsibility seriously."

The road to compliance has been arduous. Stellar's staff dedicated over 13,000 hours to overhaul policies, procedures, and bylaws, removing any content related to shared compensation. Despite these efforts, the transition has not been without hiccups. Since the rule changes began on August 6, Stellar has issued fewer than 300 fines out of approximately 14,000 new listings, with less than 2% showing compensation violations. Cowen acknowledges that while she hopes for zero fines, she is pleased with the current numbers.

Looking ahead, Cowen anticipates a period of adjustment. "Within a few months, things will settle down, and these changes will become second nature," she predicts. New agents entering the industry will find these rules as the norm from the start, potentially easing the transition for future professionals.

Yet, the landscape of real estate is still evolving. Upcoming challenges include a lawsuit challenging the "three-way agreement" which mandates automatic membership in state and national associations for local Realtors, and renewed litigation concerning NAR’s Clear Cooperation policy, which requires listings to be submitted to an MLS within one business day of public marketing.

As the industry navigates these uncharted waters, Cowen reflects on the central question for all real estate institutions: "How can we be nimble, adapt to changes, and help our customers manage these transitions effectively?"

In a world where regulatory compliance and industry norms are in flux, the journey of adaptation is as critical as it is complex. For real estate professionals and organizations alike, the road ahead will demand both resilience and flexibility.