Is Florida's Housing Market Facing a Downturn?

Photo byGetty Images

Florida — Recent reports indicate that Florida's housing market may be experiencing significant shifts. Concerns are mounting over potential market instability, driven by record-high home prices, elevated mortgage rates, and rising inventory.

Current Market Overview:

1. Inventory Surge: In March 2024, ResiClub reported that Florida saw the largest inventory increase in the nation, with 57% more homes for sale compared to the previous year (ResiClub, March 2024). This surge in inventory, coupled with slowing demand, has raised questions about the potential for a market crash.
2. Price Trends: As of June 2024, the median sales price in Florida was $419,000, marking a 2.3% increase from the previous year. Despite this slight rise, prices have stabilized since peaking in April 2024. This median price is near its historical high (Redfin, June 2024).
3. • Robert Arnold, managing broker at Sand Dollar Realty Group, notes that while official figures show record prices, he is observing price drops in Central Florida, particularly for mid-range properties (Sand Dollar Realty Group, June 2024).
   • Britt Brooks, a real estate agent with Coldwell Banker Realty, also reports a slowdown in sales and minor price reductions. However, well-priced properties continue to sell quickly (Coldwell Banker Realty, June 2024).
4. Sales and Days on Market: Data from Redfin reveals that 30.7% of Florida sellers reduced their asking prices in June 2024, a 4.5 percentage point increase from the previous year. Home sales dropped by 14.1%, with an average of 57 days from listing to closing, up from the previous year (Redfin, June 2024).
5. Supply Levels: Florida’s housing supply stood at around five months as of June 2024, a significant increase from just over two months a year prior. A five to six-month supply is generally considered balanced (Redfin, June 2024).

Factors Contributing to the Slowdown:

1. Affordability Issues: The Florida housing market, once fueled by an influx of out-of-state buyers attracted by favorable tax laws and lower living costs, is now facing affordability challenges. The median home price has increased by 60% over the past five years, with an annual appreciation rate of 12% (Redfin, June 2024).
2. • Arnold attributes the slowdown to higher mortgage rates, increased property taxes, and soaring homeowner's insurance costs, exacerbated by Hurricane Ian's impact on insurance rates (Sand Dollar Realty Group, June 2024).
3. Insurance Costs: Florida’s homeowner's insurance remains the highest in the country due to the state's vulnerability to hurricanes and floods. The insurance market has been unstable, particularly following Hurricane Ian in 2022 (Sand Dollar Realty Group, June 2024).
4. Regulatory Changes: Recent changes, such as the National Association of Realtors lawsuit settlement, may also be contributing to market uncertainty. Buyers could now face additional costs for agent fees, impacting their purchasing decisions (Coldwell Banker Realty, August 2024).
5. Condo Market Challenges: Florida's condo market is under pressure due to new state laws mandating mandatory inspections and increased HOA reserves. This has led to substantial special assessments for condo owners (Sand Dollar Realty Group, June 2024).

Outlook for Florida’s Housing Market:

While certain segments of Florida’s housing market are slowing and experiencing price reductions, experts do not foresee an imminent crash.

• Brooks suggests that the market may be rebalancing, with buyers gaining more negotiating power (Coldwell Banker Realty, June 2024).
• Arnold predicts that while prices may flatten temporarily, any decreases are likely to be modest and short-term. He remains optimistic about continued demand and growth in the long term (Sand Dollar Realty Group, June 2024).