Soaring Insurance Costs: A Stormy Challenge for U.S. Commercial Real Estate

Photo byAFP

As hurricanes lash the U.S. coast, the repercussions ripple through the commercial real estate sector, bringing with them unprecedented insurance costs that threaten to destabilize the market. The impact of climate change has become a harsh reality, as rising rates and stringent requirements from insurers create a perfect storm for owners of strip malls, apartment buildings, and office towers.

The narrative of rising insurance costs is becoming all too familiar for property owners across the nation. According to a recent report from Marsh McLennan, commercial property insurance premiums surged by an average of 11% last year, with coastal regions experiencing increases of up to 50%. This year, those rates have doubled in some of the most vulnerable areas, including California and the Gulf Coast . Such hikes come on the heels of Hurricane Helene, which devastated Florida’s Gulf Coast and inflicted an estimated $35 billion in economic losses across several states . This underscores a broader trend where no area is deemed entirely safe from the destructive force of increasingly extreme weather events.

Commercial property owners find themselves in a precarious position, caught between the demands of insurers and the stringent requirements of lenders. Mario Kilifarski, head of asset management at Fundamental Advisors, states, “This current interest-rate environment has exposed the people that know what they’re doing and those that don’t.” For many, the burden of soaring insurance costs is tipping the scales in an already strained industry, where rising interest rates and increasing labor and material expenses compound the challenges .

The financial toll is significant. For apartment buildings, insurance now accounts for approximately 8% of operating expenses—double what it was five years ago . As Paul Fiorilla of Yardi Matrix explains, while insurance remains a small fraction of overall costs, it increasingly adds to the financial strain amidst stagnant rents and higher borrowing expenses. Landlords are grappling with rising operating costs that have outpaced their income, amplifying their frustrations .

The lenders are also feeling the heat. “We’re constantly hearing from our banks,” says Kevin Kaseff, managing partner at Titan Real Estate Investment Group. His lenders are seeking reassurance about how he secures insurance, particularly in California, where some insurers have halted new business . While banks require property owners to maintain insurance policies, the stipulations are often stricter for commercial real estate borrowers. In some cases, gaining approval for policy adjustments can be nearly impossible if the loan has been securitized and sold to investors .

The consequences of these soaring costs are tangible, as Danielle Lombardo of Willis Towers Watson notes that insurance pricing has forced numerous deals to collapse, with some properties even heading toward foreclosure . A significant issue arises when costs escalate dramatically from the time a buyer begins securing financing to when the deal is about to close, often leading to missed opportunities and financial losses.

Solutions to this pressing issue seem straightforward to industry insiders. Kaseff advocates for banks to allow commercial real estate owners to opt for insurance with higher deductibles to mitigate costs or to cover only the value of the bank loan rather than the total rebuilding costs . However, banks remain hesitant, fearing that underinsured properties could destabilize the broader real estate market if disaster strikes .

Despite the hurdles, analysts maintain that the current insurance challenges, while troubling, do not signal an impending catastrophe for the sector. Nathan Stovall of S&P Global Market Intelligence reports a slight uptick in delinquency rates, currently at 1.5% of all outstanding commercial real estate loans, which is manageable compared to the 10% peak during the 2008 financial crisis .

On September 18, the Federal Reserve cut its benchmark interest rate for the first time in over a year, offering a glimmer of hope for commercial real estate owners. However, with new loans still difficult to secure and interest rates lingering higher than pre-pandemic levels, the road to recovery remains fraught with challenges .

In these turbulent times, the importance of innovative solutions and collaborative efforts cannot be overstated. As the landscape of commercial real estate evolves, so too must the strategies employed by owners, lenders, and insurers. Together, they can navigate the stormy seas ahead, ensuring that the commercial real estate market remains resilient and capable of weathering the challenges that lie ahead.