These cruise ships got the best (and worst) CDC sanitation scores
By Eve Chen, USA TODAY,
4 hours ago
Gastrointestinal illnesses like norovirus can be unfortunate anywhere, but they can be especially miserable on cruise ships, where they can easily spread without proper sanitation.
The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention’s Vessel Sanitation Program is specifically designed to help keep GI illnesses from spreading on cruises by inspecting vessels, responding to outbreaks, training ship supervisors, and more.
So far, this year, only two cruise ships have failed inspection, but several others have been close to the edge. Here’s how to find the sanitation reports for any ship sailing to the U.S.
How are ships scored?
Ships are scored on a scale of 100 for how well they’re keeping standards set in the VSP Operations Manual and given recommendations for addressing any issues.
A score of 86 or above is considered satisfactory. Anything below that is considered failing.
Three U.S. cruise lines' ships have been right at 86 this year:
Additionally, MSC Cruises’ MSC Magnifica scored an 86 in May . MSC Cruises is headquartered in Switzerland and the third largest cruise company in the world, behind Carnival Cruise Line and Royal Caribbean International.
Hapag-Lloyd Cruises ’ Hanseatic Inspiration scored a 62 in September . Among the violations, the CDC VSP report said, “Supervisors were inadequately monitoring critical and high-risk food processes, permitting unsafe practices to continue in food preparation areas” and several food items were stored at incorrect temperatures.
"Hapag-Lloyd Cruises has consistently met the strict hygiene requirements for many years with exemplary results that far exceed the required minimuum," Hapag-Lloyd Cruises senior communications manager Karen Schmidt said in a statement to USA TODAY. "We deeply regret that the HANSEATIC inspiration did not achieve the required score for the first time. The result of this inspection in no way reflects our high standards."
Schmidt said the German cruise line's immediately began investigating and rectifying operational deficiencies, and brought both inside and outside experts in to support new measures. The cruise line is also enhancing training for all employees and revising hygiene protocols across ships.
"We will use this opportunity to improve our processes in all areas and ensure that all our ships deliver the quality experience our guests expect," Schmidt added.
Only one U.S. cruise line vessel scored below 86 this year. Margaritaville at Sea Paradise scored an 83 in May , but then 92 more recently in July. Among the violations in May were several out of order appliances, no soap at a hand washing station, and too many people in the whirlpool.
Results can be narrowed by ship, cruise line, inspection date and score category.
Have any ships scored a 100?
Twenty ships have scored a perfect 100 this year:
Carnival Cruise Line’s Carnival Spirit in September
Celebrity Cruises’ Celebrity Ascent in January
Celebrity Cruises’ Celebrity Equinox in February
Disney Cruise Line’s Disney Fantasy in January
Holland America Line’s Zuiderdam in August
MSC Cruises’ Explore I in January
MSC Cruises’ MSC Meraviglia in July
MSC Cruises’ MSC Seashore in May
Norwegian Cruise Line’s Norwegian Bliss in June
Norwegian Cruise Line’s Norwegian Breakaway in February
Norwegian Cruise Line’s Norwegian Escape in January
Norwegian Cruise Line’s Norwegian Gem in January
Norwegian Cruise Line’s Norwegian Jewel in July
Norwegian Cruise Line’s Norwegian Sky in May
Oceania Cruises' Regatta in July
Royal Caribbean International’s Brilliance of the Seas in May
Royal Caribbean International’s Radiance of the Seas in July
Seabourn Cruise Line’s Seabourn Odyssey in August
Viking Expeditions’ Viking Polaris in April
Viking Ocean Cruises’ Viking Orion in August
It’s worth noting that perfect scores do not mean there is zero risk of illness. For instance, Royal Caribbean’s Radiance of the Seas scored 100 in July, but had a norovirus outbreak in April and a salmonella outbreak in September.
Which cruise ships have norovirus outbreaks?
There are currently no ships listed as having norovirus outbreaks, but at least seven ships have had norovirus outbreaks this year and several others had other outbreaks, according to the CDC VSP.
The CDC recommends washing hands often and if you see someone getting sick, leaving the area and reporting it to cruise staff.
Passengers who get sick are urged to call the ship’s medical staff as soon as possible, follow all their instructions, and get plenty of rest and water.
(This story has been updated with new information.)
Get updates delivered to you daily. Free and customizable.
It’s essential to note our commitment to transparency:
Our Terms of Use acknowledge that our services may not always be error-free, and our Community Standards emphasize our discretion in enforcing policies. As a platform hosting over 100,000 pieces of content published daily, we cannot pre-vet content, but we strive to foster a dynamic environment for free expression and robust discourse through safety guardrails of human and AI moderation.
Comments / 0