Tom Hanks' Controversial Casting Decision Behind The Scenes of 'Band of Brothers'

Band of Brothers (2001) is a widely acclaimed miniseries celebrated for its portrayal of the wartime experiences of Easy Company, 2nd Battalion, 506th Parachute Infantry Regiment, 101st Airborne Division . Featuring a blended cast of established and emerging actors , it begins with a captivating prologue from real-life veterans.

Yet, before filming started, Connor Ratliff was unexpectedly removed from the project by Tom Hanks. But what led to this decision?

Connor Ratliff successfully auditioned for Band of Brothers

During HBO's casting sessions for Band of Brothers , Connor Ratliff embarked on his entertainment career. He took a break from his studies at the University of Missouri to fully dedicate himself to acting, refining his skills at the Liverpool Institute of Performing Arts (LIPA). The miniseries, adapted from Stephen E. Ambrose's book and involving industry giants like Tom Hanks and Steven Spielberg , presented a major career opportunity.

After several rounds of auditions, Ratliff learned he had landed the role of Pvt. John S. Zielinski Jr. Although a supporting role, it provided important screen time alongside Damian Lewis, who played Maj. Richard Winters. However, Tom Hanks was notably absent from Ratliff's audition.

Tom Hanks had his say... And the answer wasn't good

Connor Ratliff was thrilled to be cast in Band of Brothers , and his excitement only grew when he learned Tom Hanks would be directing his episode.

"I was very excited," he told The Telegraph years later. "They cut my hair. I remember the experience of going to the airbase and getting a costume fitting, and it was just such a huge production. And then I found out great news, like, the best news of all: Tom Hanks is directing your episode."

However, things took a turn for the worse just a day before filming was scheduled to start.

"The day before I was supposed to film, I got a call from someone in my agent's office, saying you need to get to London right now," Ratliff recounted. "I said, I'm going later this afternoon, I have a train ticket. They were like, no, go to the train station. Now. Get on a train, get to London. Tom Hanks has seen your audition tape and he's having second thoughts. He thinks you have dead eyes."

Upon arriving in London, Ratliff had to re-audition for the role of Pvt. Zielinski, this time in front of Hanks. Sadly, it wasn't meant to be, as he was informed they'd decided to go in a different direction , opting for someone with a more military-like presence.

The role ultimately went to Adam Sims.

Connor Ratliff takes a decade-long break from acting

Naturally, Connor Ratliff faced a major disappointment when he was unexpectedly dropped from his role in Band of Brothers . The setback, combined with other obstacles in his acting career, proved so emotionally draining that he decided to take a break from acting.

However, this didn’t mean he vanished from the public eye. Shortly after, he discovered improv comedy, and the rest is, as they say, history! Ratliff quickly gained recognition as one of the standout performers at New York’s Upright Citizens Brigade. Although he initially showed disinterest, he eventually returned to the stage, this time on The Chris Gethard Show (2011-18).

This comeback led to more opportunities, including roles on The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel (2017-23), The Blacklist (2013-23), and Search Party (2016-22). He’s also had the unique opportunity to portray Star Wars creator George Lucas on both The George Lucas Talk Show (2020-present) and the podcast series Double Threat with Julie Klausner & Tom Scharpling.

Turning rejection into a hit podcast

Despite his success, Connor Ratliff has never forgotten about his Band of Brothers snub - and he's since used it to develop a hit podcast. Aptly titled Dead Eyes , the show focuses on not only the impact the rejection had on his career, but also explores how such events can foster creative opportunities.

"My favorite thing that people will sometimes say on the podcast is, 'I started listening to it, hoping that we'd get to an ending. And now, I hope it doesn't. I hope you don't get what you're looking for.' In a way, the mystery is the hook," he explained to The Telegraph .

As it's grown in popularity, Dead Eyes has afforded Ratliff the opportunity to speak with several high-profile guests, such as Elijah Wood, Jon Hamm, Zach Braff and Judd Apatow. He's even spoken with Tom Hanks' son, Colin, who reacted to the story by saying Ratliff's experience was " the exact opposite " of the reputation Hanks has developed within Hollywood.

In reality, this is the reason why the incident has stuck with Ratliff. "If I'd been up for a James Cameron thing and he was like, 'I don't know, you have dead eyes,' it would've hurt me, but I would've thought, like, Oh well, James Cameron is tough," Ratliff told Vanity Fair . "If I had been up for, you know, a little role in Eyes Wide Shut and Stanley Kubrick said, 'You have dead eyes,' I would've been like, In his case, I don't know if that means I've got the part! The classic Kubrick stare is dead eyes."

Connor Ratliff finally got a response from Tom Hanks

It was only a matter of time before Connor Ratliff spoke to Tom Hanks himself, and that moment came in March 2022. The actor appeared on an episode of Dead Eyes , and what could have been an awkward moment turned out to be cathartic for Ratliff.

When confronted with the comedian's story, Hanks commented that "not a single moment of this rings a bell." However, that didn't stop him from apologizing to Ratliff. What's more, the apology shows just how much this incident weighed on the actor, despite his not remembering it.

"Let me first take full responsibility for doing this to you," Hanks said. "This was without a doubt the act of the director, and that was me." He added that it was "one of those very, very subtle sort of decisions that aims the story in the direction you want it to go."

He further revealed that he was "aghast" when he heard how his actions had impacted Ratliff.

"I actually got chilled," he explained. "My heart rate skyrocketed and I said, I did ... I did what? I did what? In the inner sanctum of whatever this casting session was on Band of Brothers ... I'm sure I said, 'I don't know man, that guy's got dead eyes.' I could've said, 'He's got too blond of hair; he's too tall and I can't have the aide be taller than Captain Winters.' I could've said, 'He's too short and slight'.

"I could've said any of these things, and they would have been true and they would've been the opinion. Whoever communicated to you what was said, in the inner sanctum, with such authenticity, should have their kneecaps broken, because that is ... That is not allowed," Hanks added. "It's not quotable there. It's off the record."

More from us: Before Becoming Hollywood's Leading Man, Kirk Douglas was Chasing Japanese Submarines in the Pacific

Want to become a trivia master? Sign up for our War History Fact of the Day newsletter!

The interaction also saw Ratliff show Hanks his old headshot, to which the actor commented, "These are not dead eyes. Can I just say that right now from this 8x10 black and white."