Five Below vs. Dollar Tree: Which Store Is the Best Bang for Your Buck?

Many bargain shoppers love Five Below and Dollar Tree for their low-priced deals, but with Dollar Tree expanding some of its offerings, these stores are more competitive than ever.

You can seriously save money shopping when you take advantage of these value stores’ prices, but which one has the better deals?

Editor’s note: Prices are subject to change and may vary by location.

Don't Miss: 9 ways to tackle high grocery costs you won't hear about from your grocery store

1. Five Below Iced Coffee vs. Dollar Tree Iced Coffee

Courtesy of FinanceBuzz

Price: $3.29 vs. $3.75

You can save money at Five Below by buying the mocha-flavored Dunkin’ iced coffee, which costs over $0.45 more compared to the Frappuccino at Dollar Tree.

Both give you nearly 14 ounces of delicious, creamy coffee you can bring with you anywhere, but this Five Below find wins this round for its price.

2. Five Below Candle vs. Dollar Tree Candle

Courtesy of Dollar Tree

Price: $5.55 vs. $5.00

At Dollar Tree, you can get a variety of 11-ounce scented candles for just $5 each, while the Five Below candles only give you seven ounces at $0.55 more.

Though the Five Below dessert candles have fun designs, the Dollar Tree options are more cost-effective, especially if you want to freshen up your space with a lovely aroma.

3. Five Below Sports Drink vs. Dollar Tree Sports Drink

Courtesy of FinanceBuzz

Price: $1.99 vs. $2.25

You can buy a 28-ounce Powerade at Five Below or spend a quarter more at Dollar Tree for 20 ounces of Gatorade.

These deals are convenient in a pinch, but you’re getting more for your money with Five Below. Each sports drink is sure to keep you hydrated, but both brands have comparable flavors, and Powerade offers a bigger bottle for less.

Make Money: 8 things to do if you’re barely scraping by financially

4. Five Below Wall Decor vs. Dollar Tree Wall Decor

Courtesy of Five Below

Price: $5.55 vs. $5.00

You can decorate your space for under $6 at these stores, but Five Below has even better savings.

Both stores have limited options for wall signs, but these are great for decorating any home on a budget.

Each hanging wall sign from Dollar Tree is $5, but the Five Below find gives you three themed canvas designs for $5.55, making this the better offer.

5. Five Below Tumbler vs. Dollar Tree Tumbler

Courtesy of FinanceBuzz

Price: $5.00 vs. $5.00

These tumblers make it easy to bring your favorite hot or cold drinks with you anywhere, and they both come in stylish color choices.

However, a 30-ounce tumbler at Five Below is the same price as a 20-ounce from Dollar Tree, making it the more budget-friendly option.

6. Five Below Chips vs. Dollar Tree Chips

Courtesy of FinanceBuzz

Price: $2.69 vs. $2.50

You can get your favorite Doritos flavors from both stores, but buying at Dollar Tree will save you $0.19.

Dollar Tree’s snack zone has a ton of low-priced offerings, like your favorite chips, candy, and more, and they’re full of exclusive prices to help you save.

Five Below has similar offerings, but Dollar Tree wins this round thanks to the almost $0.20 difference.

7. Five Below Serving Tray vs. Dollar Tree Serving Tray

Courtesy of FinanceBuzz

Price: $5.00 vs. $5.00

Each serving tray will cost $5, but one might be a better deal for your party needs.

The Five Below tray is more of a chip-and-dip display, but it has two fun summery designs: palm leaves and a pink citrus style.

The wooden serving tray from Dollar Tree is convenient for other purposes, like having breakfast in bed or organizing crafts, so these two options really depend on your preference.

8. Five Below Sunglasses vs. Dollar Tree Sunglasses

Courtesy of FinanceBuzz

Price: $5.00 vs. $1.50

If you’re looking for sun protection, you’ve got it with these affordable sunglasses.

You can save $3.50 when you buy a pair of polarized sunglasses from Dollar Tree, and you still have plenty of chic styles to choose from.

Just because you’re spending more at Five Below for a similar item doesn’t mean the quality is any better, so Dollar Tree also wins this round.

9. Five Below Bluetooth Speaker vs. Dollar Tree Bluetooth Speaker

Courtesy of Dollar Tree

Price: $7.00 vs. $5.00

Why spend an extra $2 on a Bluetooth speaker when both offer similar features?

Each portable speaker pairs via Bluetooth and is compact and colorful, so you’ll get your money’s worth in either option.

The cheaper Dollar Tree speaker even has color-changing lights while your music, audiobooks, or podcasts play.

10. Five Below Throw Blanket vs. Dollar Tree Throw Blanket

Courtesy of Dollar Tree

Price: $5.00 vs. $5.00

Here’s another category where the price tags might just be deceiving.

These throw blankets are $5 each, but the Dollar Tree option is a softer design with a range of patterns, while the Five Below throw is made with a stiffer fabric.

They’re around the same size (50x60 for Dollar Tree, 48x60 for Five Below), so you’re still spending less on something sure to keep you cozy.

Bottom line

Though some of these items are less expensive, the quality and longevity of a lower price point are worth considering.

Five Below and Dollar Tree both have unique selections that can help you save on groceries , home goods, and more.

More from FinanceBuzz:

Get Out of Debt for Good: Try these 6 clever ways to crush your debt.