Should You End a Relationship? Research Reveals Key Factors to Consider

Photo byPriscilla Du Preez 🇨🇦onUnsplash

Deciding whether to end a relationship is a complex and challenging process. Should one put in more effort to make things work, or is it time to accept that too much energy has already been expended?

Weighing the Pros and Cons

A practical approach to this dilemma is making a list of pros and cons. Research from 2018, published in Social Psychology and Personality Science, revealed that most individuals can enumerate reasons both for staying in and leaving a relationship.

Analyzing responses from 447 participants, the study identified 27 reasons people consider when contemplating their relationship.

Common reasons to stay included emotional and physical intimacy, family responsibilities, and financial benefits.

On the flip side, reasons to leave encompassed breaches of trust, unsatisfactory sexual experiences, excessive conflict, incompatibility, disliking the partner's personality, and finding someone new.

The Investment Model

The investment model is a framework researchers use to understand what influences the decision to stay or leave a relationship. According to this model, three factors contribute to commitment:

1. Relationship Satisfaction: This measures the balance of positive and negative experiences with a partner. High satisfaction indicates that one's needs are being met.
2. Investments in the Relationship: These are the resources that would be lost if the relationship ended. They include financial investments, shared possessions, children, mutual friends, and connections with in-laws.
3. Quality of Alternatives: This refers to the availability of other fulfilling relationships or activities outside the current relationship, such as potential new partners, friends, family, or hobbies.

The model posits that relationship satisfaction and investments boost commitment, while attractive alternatives diminish it. Ideally, a person would feel highly satisfied, have significant investments in the relationship, and perceive alternatives as less appealing compared to their current partner.

But these factors can be complex and interwoven. For instance, individuals may misjudge their potential to find a new partner or pursue hobbies, thus skewing their perception of available choices.

Consider Mina, who enjoys her time with Josh but is also intrigued by her colleague Jeff, who shares many of her interests. Despite high satisfaction and recent investments in her relationship with Josh, Mina might opt to pursue a potential relationship with Jeff, illustrating the model's complexity.

Even if Mina carefully weighs the pros and cons of her relationship with Josh, she can't be sure if Jeff shares her vision for a future together, making her final decision a risky bet.

Fear of Breaking Up

Even when faced with potential benefits of ending a relationship, fear often keeps people from doing so. Breakups are associated with emotional distress, health issues, and a loss of identity. Additionally, people might miss goals that were facilitated by their partner.

The fear of being single can lead individuals to settle for less than they deserve. This fear is closely tied to a fear of regret, which biases people towards maintaining the status quo despite logical or intuitive reasons to end the relationship.

Social stigma around being single further complicates the decision. Single individuals are often perceived as lonelier and less happy than those in relationships, adding societal pressure to stay coupled.

Navigating the Decision

If you're contemplating a breakup, try to objectively assess the positives and negatives of your relationship, the investments you’ve made, and the realistic alternatives you have. Consider whether fear is a motivating factor. While it’s possible to reignite a spark in a long-term relationship, staying out of fear is unfair to both partners.

If you find yourself newly single, lean on friends and family for support. Reflect on what you’ve learned from the relationship and how it has contributed to your personal growth. Embrace the positives of a single life, focusing on your goals and needs without the need to compromise.