Get updates delivered to you daily. Free and customizable.
TMJ4 News
Menomonee Falls bakery reopens after owners receive 'threatening messages'
By Mariam Mackar, Katlin Connin,
2024-05-13
A bakery in Menomonee Falls reopened Wednesday morning. The bakery is normally closed Monday and Tuesday, and Wednesday is the first time they'll be open since receiving backlash over a planned 'Drag Story Hour and Cupcake Decorating' event.
Co-owners Kasey Gusho and Brittany Wohlfeil say they canceled the event after receiving 'threatening' and 'violent' messages. Despite that pushback, there are plenty of people wanting to support the small business.
The pair of owners say they've received plenty of messages of support on social media — with people commenting "their bakery is out of this world," and "there is no room for hate."
TMJ4 Batter & Mac bakery in Menomonee Falls
The event at Batter and Mac was scheduled as a fundraiser for Courage MKE , which helps advocate for LGBTQ people in our community, as well as helping them find housing, scholarships grants, and more.
"We were going to have the kids come in, read a book about love and acceptance, decorate some cupcakes, and just have a good and fun time to raise money for Courage MKE," said co-owner Brittany Wohlfeil.
According to a Facebook post from Batter and Mac , "These events are a great tool for promoting creativity in your minds, tearing down stereotypes, and promoting inclusion."
Wohlfeil went on to say in the post that others in the community did not agree with the event, and that "the messages we received regarding this event have become threatening in a violent nature."
Co-owner Kasey Gusho said they received a number of threatening calls from 'no-caller ID' numbers telling them to shut down the event.
"We were being called a lot of names — a lot of names," explained Gusho. "It was overwhelming and just kind of sad and just disappointing."
It was then that Gusho and Wohlfeil decided to cancel the event out of concern for patron, staff, performer, and neighborhood safety.
Batter and Mac says it is still hosting its Drag Bingo Night, which is sold out, and adding another date due to high demand.
They also just opened up ticket sales for a "Chopped" style competition, which will also benefit Courage MKE.
TMJ4, Mariam Mackar Brittany Wohlfeil and Kasey Gusho are the co-owners of Batter & Mac in Menomonee Falls.
Other Facebook posts show Menomonee Falls Village Trustee, Ann Lessila, was one of the people vocally against the event.
Lessila replied "spread the word" to a commenter saying they will no longer be shopping at the bakery.
She also wrote in response to the backlash on her trustee Facebook page: "I am going to leave all of the comments on my page so it's out in the public who wants to groom children."
Mackar reached out to Lessila for comment. She sent back an email saying she "believes the community deserves to know the details of the event."
"Shouldn't we support those who do good for others, regardless of who they're doing good for?" asked Courage MKE executive director, Brad Schlaikowski. "[Drag] is a person in a costume in makeup. That's all it is. If it's anything bigger than that to you it's because you made it that way."
Despite the controversy Batter and Mac owners say they will continue raising funds in June for Courage MKE.
"Bakery is for everybody. Our bakery is for everybody and we try to welcome everybody," said Wohlfeil. "Even if you disagree with us, you’re still welcome here."
Talk to us: At TMJ4 News, we make every effort to listen to you and follow up on the issues that matter to you personally. If you have a story idea, tip, or comment about this story, let us know using the form below. Visit tmj4.com/tips for more ways to reach out to us and make your voice heard. Name Email Message Verification:
It’s about time to watch on your time. Stream local news and weather 24/7 by searching for “TMJ4” on your device.
Get updates delivered to you daily. Free and customizable.
It’s essential to note our commitment to transparency:
Our Terms of Use acknowledge that our services may not always be error-free, and our Community Standards emphasize our discretion in enforcing policies. As a platform hosting over 100,000 pieces of content published daily, we cannot pre-vet content, but we strive to foster a dynamic environment for free expression and robust discourse through safety guardrails of human and AI moderation.
Comments / 0