Stricter Camping Ban in Bristol Raises Concerns for Homeless

Photo byLeroy SkalstadonUnsplash

BRISTOL, Va. —The Bristol City Council has approved stricter penalties for camping on public property and in city parks, a move that could significantly impact the city's homeless population. The new ordinance, passed on Tuesday night, hardens the city's stance on public camping, expanding the scope of a 2022 ban and elevating the punishment for violations, according to minutes from the city council meeting

The council's decision, which follows a divided vote during the ordinance's first reading on August 13, officially amends the existing ban to include city parks and raises the offense from a Class 4 misdemeanor to a Class 1 misdemeanor. This change increases the maximum penalty to 12 months in jail and a $2,500 fine, a substantial jump from the previous $250 acceptable limit. The revised ordinance is set to take effect on September 26, 30 days after its final passage.

Mayor Becky Nave emphasized that the new law is not intended to criminalize homelessness but to address concerns raised by local business owners and public safety officials. "We're not wanting to set this up so we can just start arresting homeless people," Nave said. "It's not illegal to be homeless. We want to help them, and we have spent quite a bit of time creating a resource guide because, just like we heard tonight, some people were saying we don’t have resources—we do."

To mitigate the impact on those experiencing homelessness, Vice Mayor Jake Holmes has created an information card listing phone numbers and resources that police and advocates can provide to individuals displaced by the ban. The city hopes that these resources, which include local shelters and employment opportunities, will offer alternatives to those affected.

However, critics argue that the increased penalties could exacerbate the challenges the homeless community faces. Councilman Neal Osborne expressed concern over the amendment's harsher punishments during the first reading, noting that the homeless often have limited options. "When we increase the severity of punishment for those with nowhere else to sleep, we need to consider the broader implications," Osborne said.

The new ordinance also removes an exception for individuals sleeping in motor vehicles on city property, further tightening restrictions. This change could leave those who rely on their cars for shelter with even fewer options.

Local advocacy groups have warned that the amendment may lead to unintended consequences, including higher rates of incarceration for non-violent offenses and increased strain on social services. According to the National Coalition for the Homeless, criminalizing homelessness can often push people further into poverty and make it harder for them to find stable housing and employment.

Bristol's decision reflects a broader trend seen in cities across the country, where local governments grapple with managing visible homelessness without adequate housing and social services. As the new rules take effect, the city's homeless population may face heightened risks, highlighting the ongoing debate over how best to address homelessness in urban areas.

Impact on Homeless Population

The expanded camping ban and increased penalties may lead to a rise in arrests among the homeless community, potentially overwhelming local jails and social services. Critics argue that such measures do not address the root causes of homelessness and may make it harder for affected individuals to access the help they need.

City officials respond to concerns by pointing to the available resources, but advocates argue that more comprehensive solutions, such as affordable housing and mental health services, are necessary to address the issue effectively.

As Bristol implements the new ordinance, the city will be closely watched to see how these changes impact the homeless population and the broader community.

Sources:

• Bristol Herald Courier: Original reporting on the ordinance changes in Bristol.
• WCYB News Channel 5: Coverage of the City Council meetings and Mayor Nave's statements.
• National Coalition for the Homeless: Data and analysis on the impacts of criminalizing homelessness.
• Bristol City Council meeting minutes: Details of the vote and Councilman Osborne’s comments.