What's the Secret Behind This Local Spot's Unbeatable Streak?

NEW PROVIDENCE, NJ - In a state where diners are as ubiquitous as traffic circles and Bruce Springsteen fans, one establishment continues to reign supreme. Prestige Diner in New Providence has once again claimed the title of Best Diner in New Jersey Monthly's annual Readers' Poll , marking an impressive fifth consecutive year at the top. Prestige Diner's enduring appeal suggests they've mastered more than just the art of the perfect omelet.

"It's about creating a community," says Harry Vardas, co-owner of Prestige Diner. "We're not just serving food; we're serving memories."

CLICK HERE TO SIGN UP FOR THE FREE TAPINTO.NET NEWSLETTER

Indeed, a visit to Prestige Diner reveals why it's captured the public's hearts. The aroma of freshly brewed coffee mingles with the sizzle of bacon on the grill, creating an atmosphere that's both comforting and invigorating. The menu, while extensive, doesn't sacrifice quality for quantity – a common pitfall in the diner world.

"We listen to our customers when we're walking around the diner," says Dimitrios Vadas, brother to Harry and co-owner of Prestige Diner. "We always strive to meet and exceed their expectations and give them a delight, like craft beers and cocktails, gluten-free and vegetarian options, and a revolving menu of seasonal specials."

But what truly sets Prestige apart is its ability to evolve while maintaining its classic diner charm. Recent additions to the menu include health-conscious, gluten-free options and locally sourced ingredients, appealing to a new generation of diner enthusiasts without alienating longtime patrons.

This balance is reflected in the diverse clientele. On any given day, you might see a group of teenagers huddled over milkshakes, a family enjoying a post-Little League breakfast, and solo diners engrossed in the conversation with the servers.

DOWNLOAD THE FREE TAPINTO APP FOR MORE LOCAL NEWS. AVAILABLE IN THE APPLE STORE AND THE GOOGLE PLAY STORE .

The diner's success is part of a broader trend in New Jersey's culinary landscape. Yet, in this competitive environment, Prestige Diner continues to shine. Its five-year winning streak is not just a testament to its quality but also to its consistency – a rare commodity in the restaurant world.

Located at 1318 Springfield Avenue in New Providence, the Vardas family takes pride in continuing the legacy of the diner,​ which began when their uncle Tommy bought the diner in 1981. ​Throughout their tenure, the Vardas have infused family and friends into everything they do, including naming favorite dishes after the owner's children (Sofia, Christopher, Paiko, and Michael​) and loyal, long-time customers, like "Scott's Zero Hero Omelette."

For those who haven't experienced Prestige Diner firsthand, now might be the time. Whether you're a diner aficionado or a casual eater, there's something to be said for tasting what New Jersey voters have consistently deemed the best.  How often do you get to dine with a five-time champion?

To learn more about Prestige Diner, its menu , and their loyalty program , visit their website or contact 908.665.0211 for inquiries or to place an online order.

For more local news, visit TAPinto.net