Redefining ‘Home’: Creative Solutions for First-Time Buyers Facing High Prices

Photo byGetty Images

In today’s ultra-competitive housing market, the idea of “home” is undergoing a transformation. With prices for traditional single-family houses reaching record highs, many prospective buyers—especially young first-timers—are rethinking what homeownership can look like. Instead of waiting on the sidelines, some are choosing to expand their definition of what a “home” can be, exploring alternative housing options that align with their budgets and lifestyles.

The Struggle with Traditional Home Affordability

The dream of owning a traditional single-family home has become increasingly elusive. In June 2024, the median sale price for such homes hit an eye-watering $432,700, according to the National Association of Realtors (NAR). This staggering price tag is a direct result of a fundamental economic imbalance: demand far outstrips supply.

Many homeowners are locked into mortgages with historically low interest rates, giving them little incentive to sell and move, especially with today’s higher rates. At the same time, builders are struggling to construct new homes quickly enough to meet demand. “The pace of new construction is even lower than it was in early 2021,” notes Mark Hamrick, senior economic analyst at Bankrate. This ongoing housing shortage has made it tough for first-time buyers to enter the market, forcing them to explore other options.

Shifting from Owning to Renting—and Back Again

This challenging environment isn’t just affecting buyers—it’s also pushing some current homeowners to rethink their strategies. In Chicago, broker Nathan Binkley of Compass has observed a surprising trend: condo owners selling their units to become renters again. “They’re looking to upgrade to single-family homes, but the numbers don’t add up,” Binkley explains. “So, they’re cashing in on the equity from their condo sales and renting until they’re ready to make their next move.”

Exploring Overlooked Housing Options

In light of these obstacles, more people are redefining what “home” means to them. According to Bankrate’s 2024 Home Affordability Report, 44% of U.S. adults would consider downsizing their living space to find something affordable. For Gen Z, the willingness to adjust is even higher—38% would take on roommates or live with family members to make homeownership a reality.

One of the most straightforward solutions is to think smaller. Condos and townhouses offer a more affordable entry into the housing market. The nationwide median price for condos in June 2024 was $371,700—over $60,000 less than the median price for single-family homes. In markets like California, the difference is even more pronounced, with condos and townhomes costing over $200,000 less than single-family homes.

“Go into your home search with realistic expectations,” advises Binkley. “A lot of couples feel they need a three-bedroom house with a guest suite for occasional visitors. I tell them they can save a lot by opting for a smaller place and putting their in-laws up in a nice hotel when they visit.”

Starting small doesn’t mean settling—it’s a strategic step toward building equity and saving for your dream home down the road. Whether it’s buying a condo, considering a unit in a multifamily home, or expanding your search to more affordable neighborhoods, the path to homeownership might just be a bit different than you originally imagined.